Connect with us

Alabama

Alabama commission lowers approved returns for a major gas company

Published

 

on

Natural gas processing facility with extensive pipelines, valves, and industrial equipment.

Alabama utility ruling hits home

A utility decision may sound far away from everyday life, but it can eventually show up on a monthly bill. Alabama regulators have made a major ruling involving Spire Alabama, a natural gas company serving roughly 500,000 customers across the state.

The Alabama Public Service Commission cut the return on equity Spire Alabama can earn to 9.4% for the next two years. At the same time, customers will see changes in how some costs are collected. The decision aims to balance utility investment needs with concerns about what households pay.

Officials at a senate meeting.

Regulators cut Spire’s requested return

Spire Alabama asked regulators to approve a 10.5% return on equity. The Alabama Public Service Commission instead approved a 9.4% adjustment point for the next two years, below both the company’s request and its previous 9.7% midpoint.

The Alabama Attorney General’s Office had recommended an even lower 9.2% adjustment point. PSC Executive Director Luke Bentley IV, who served as administrative law judge, said the Attorney General’s recommendation was the most reasonable and more accurately reflected Spire Alabama’s cost of equity.

Monthly utility bills.

Monthly charges will still rise

The lower return does not mean every part of a customer’s bill will stay the same. Regulators approved a phased increase in Spire Alabama’s fixed monthly customer charge, adding $2.50 starting October 1, 2026.

Another $2.50 increase is scheduled for the same date in 2027. Together, the changes will raise the monthly fixed charge by $5. Customers may notice the difference even though regulators say the overall adjustment is designed to keep total utility revenue neutral rather than increase the company’s overall collections

Closeup view of multiple utility bills placed on a table.

Why bills may stay steady for now

The commission said the customer-charge change is revenue neutral for Spire overall because more fixed costs will be collected through the monthly charge while the usage-based portion of rates is reduced.

Individual customers may still see different effects depending on how much natural gas they use. PSC President Cynthia Almond said the change shifts part of the recovery of fixed customer costs away from the usage-based portion of the bill and into the recurring monthly charge.

People at a business meeting.

Spire Gulf also faces a lower return

The commission also ruled on Spire Gulf, a sister company serving customers along Alabama’s Gulf Coast. Spire Gulf had requested a 10.75% return on equity, but regulators approved a lower 9.6% return.

That new figure is also below the nearly 10% return the company currently receives. The decisions show that the commission took a tougher approach toward both Spire companies during the rate process. Energy Alabama had pushed for an even deeper reduction, suggesting returns closer to 8.3%.

Public speaker at business conference, corporate presentation, workshop, coaching training, news conference, company meeting, public or political event

The company says growth could suffer

Spire representatives said they were disappointed by the commission’s decision. Reynolds Anderson, vice president of external affairs for Spire Energy, said the lower approved returns could affect the company’s ability to invest in growth and economic development.

The company argued that its requested returns were based partly on rates approved for other utilities. Spire says investment is important for expanding service and supporting communities as Alabama seeks new businesses and development.

Despite its objections, the company said it remains committed to providing safe and reliable natural gas service.

Judge sitting with a gavel on the table.

A rare rate case changed the process

This was not an ordinary regulatory review. The hearing was part of a formal rate case announced after Spire and the Alabama Attorney General’s Office failed to agree on an appropriate Rate Stabilization Equalization figure.

The case was especially notable because it was the first rate case convened by the Alabama Public Service Commission since the 1980s. That made the proceedings a rare opportunity for regulators to closely examine the utility’s requested returns.

Inside view of a senate chamber with multiple politicians in a meeting.

The Attorney General had a key role

The Alabama Attorney General’s Office played a major role in the outcome. The commission said its decision was based largely on the office’s recommendation for a lower return on equity for Spire Alabama.

Luke Bentley IV, the PSC executive director who served as the administrative law judge during the hearing, said the Attorney General’s recommendation was the most reasonable and better reflected Spire Alabama’s cost of equity.

The ruling highlights how state offices can influence utility decisions that may eventually affect millions of dollars in customer payments and corporate investment plans.

An oil and gas refinery.

Alabama energy costs remain a concern

The ruling comes as Alabama residents continue watching utility costs closely. According to federal energy data cited in the debate, Alabama residents paid about 16.4 cents per kilowatt-hour for electricity in June, above the regional average of 14.89 cents.

Those figures involve electricity rather than Spire’s natural gas service, but they show why energy bills have become a bigger public issue across the state.

Rising household expenses have increased pressure on regulators to examine utility charges carefully while also considering the money companies need to maintain and expand their systems.

Little-known fact: Alabama had 799,428 residential natural gas consumers in 2024, according to federal energy data.

Person speaking while gesturing during formal meeting.

Consumer advocates welcomed the decision

Energy Alabama, a nonprofit that advocates for clean energy and utility affordability, praised the commission’s decision to reduce Spire’s returns. The group said it was pleased to see regulators bring the company’s return on equity down.

Still, advocates had wanted a bigger reduction. Energy Alabama suggested that Spire Alabama and Spire Gulf receive returns closer to 8.3%. The final figures of 9.4% and 9.6% landed between the company requests and the deeper cuts sought by the nonprofit, showing how utility regulation often involves competing financial priorities.

Fun fact: The Alabama Public Service Commission was officially designated in 1915 and grew out of the state’s earlier Railroad Commission.

Judge holding lawsuit documents near advocate and prosecutor.

New laws reshaped the commission

The rate case came after Alabama lawmakers approved major changes to the Public Service Commission. A new law expands the commission from three members to seven, and Gov. Kay Ivey has appointed four additional commissioners whose initial terms begin January 18, 2027.

The structure will gradually transition toward commissioners elected from congressional districts on staggered schedules. The law also creates a cabinet-level Secretary of Energy beginning January 19, 2027, with authority over PSC administration and meeting agendas.

For formal electric-utility rate hearings after January 1, 2029, the law requires either direction from the Secretary of Energy or approval from at least five of the seven commissioners.

State council members.

Future rate cases face new hurdles

Beginning January 19, 2027, Alabama’s new Secretary of Energy will be a cabinet-level official appointed by the governor. The secretary will direct PSC activities and set commission meeting agendas, although at least five commissioners can vote to amend an agenda.

After the freeze on retail electric base-rate increases ends January 1, 2029, a formal electric-rate hearing can be triggered either by the Secretary of Energy or by an affirmative vote of at least five of the seven commissioners. Those rules will give the new office and a PSC supermajority important roles in future electric-rate reviews.

Find out why new research is raising concerns about Alabama’s patchwork system of local court fees.

An elderly woman considers payments for utility bills on a

What Alabama customers should watch next

For customers, the biggest question is how these changes will appear on future bills. The fixed monthly charge is set to rise in two stages, while the usage-based portion is being adjusted so the restructuring remains revenue neutral for Spire overall.

The broader regulatory story is also worth watching. Alabama’s expanded commission and new rules governing future formal electric-rate hearings could reshape how some major rate disputes are handled after 2029. Spire’s lower approved returns may also influence future debates about utility investment, customer costs, and regulation.

Discover why Alabama regulators unanimously approved a massive 200-megawatt solar project and battery storage facility designed to support Meta’s Montgomery data center.

What do you think about this decision? Let us know in the comments, and don’t forget to leave a like.

This slideshow was made with AI assistance and human editing.

Read More From This Brand:

Simon is a globe trotter who loves to write about travel. Trying new foods and immersing himself in different cultures is his passion. After visiting 24 countries and 18 states, he knows he has a lot more places to see! Learn more about Simon on Muck Rack.

Trending Posts