Walmart Is Ripping Out Self-Checkout Lanes After Years of Pushing Them on Shoppers

Retails Automation Bet Backfires Big

Walmart spent years replacing cashiers with self-checkout machines. Customers would scan their own groceries, bag their own stuff, and do it all for free.

The company saved money on labor. Everyone wins, right?

Not quite. Theft went through the roof.

Customers got frustrated. And now America’s biggest retailer is pulling the plug on self-checkout lanes at stores across the country. They’re not the only ones backing away from the machines.

Theft Losses Ate the Savings

The math was supposed to be simple. Fewer cashiers meant lower labor costs.

But retailers didn’t count on how much product would walk out the door.

Inventory shrink from theft and scanning errors cost the retail industry an estimated $112 billion in 2022. Self-checkout made stealing easier because nobody was watching every scan.

Customers could skip items, swap barcodes, or just walk out. The savings from cutting cashier hours vanished into shoplifters’ pockets.

Customers Hated the Free Labor

Shoppers figured out pretty quickly what was happening. They were doing the cashier’s job without getting paid for it.

Scanning groceries, bagging everything, dealing with machines that couldn’t read barcodes. A 2023 survey found that 67 percent of shoppers had experienced a self-checkout failure.

The machines were supposed to be faster.

Instead, people stood there waiting for help while the robot voice yelled about unexpected items in the bagging area.

Dollar General Pulled 12,000 Stores

Walmart isn’t the first to reverse course. Dollar General made an even bigger move in 2024, removing self-checkout from roughly 12,000 of its stores.

The discount chain had leaned hard into automation, but inventory losses got so bad that executives couldn’t ignore it anymore. They brought back staffed registers and added more workers to the floor.

The company admitted the experiment had gone too far.

Target Cut It Down to 10 Items

Target took a different approach. Instead of removing self-checkout entirely, they limited it to customers with 10 items or fewer.

The express lane concept made sense on paper. Small baskets, quick transactions, in and out.

But it also meant customers with full carts had to wait for actual cashiers, which meant Target had to staff those registers again. The labor savings shrank.

Five Below Ripped Out 300 Machines

The discount chain Five Below joined the retreat in 2024, removing self-checkout from over 300 stores. The company found that the machines didn’t work well for their business model.

Everything in the store costs around five bucks, which makes it easy to grab stuff and skip the scanner. They decided human cashiers were worth the cost.

The Machines Made Stealing Easy

Self-checkout depends on one thing: customers being honest. Scan every item, pay the full price, walk out.

But the system has no real way to enforce that. Security cameras and weight sensors catch some theft, but not enough.

Organized retail crime rings figured out how to game the machines years ago. Regular shoppers learned that accidentally forgetting to scan something had zero consequences.

Staff Still Babysat the Lanes

Here’s the part retailers didn’t advertise. Self-checkout never actually eliminated cashier jobs.

Someone had to stand there monitoring the machines, clearing errors, checking IDs, and catching theft. Stores needed almost as many workers as before, just doing different tasks.

The big labor savings existed mostly in corporate presentations, not on the actual floor.

Alcohol Created a Bottleneck

Every time someone scanned a bottle of wine, the machine locked up. A staff member had to walk over, verify the customer’s age, and clear the transaction.

Same with tobacco, certain cold medicines, and spray paint. The delays piled up.

Customers waited in line while one employee tried to manage eight machines at once. The speed advantage disappeared completely.

Some Walmarts Went Members-Only

Several Walmart locations tried a middle path. Instead of removing self-checkout, they restricted it to Walmart Plus members.

If you pay the annual subscription fee, you get to use the machines. Everyone else goes to a staffed register.

The move pushes customers toward the paid membership while reducing theft from anonymous shoppers.

British Retailer Booths Quit Completely

Across the Atlantic, UK grocery chain Booths made headlines in 2023 by removing self-checkout from all but two of its stores. The company called it a return to real customer service.

Shoppers wanted human interaction, not a fight with a malfunctioning screen. Booths positioned the move as a competitive advantage, not a retreat.

Cashiers Are Coming Back

The pullback means something unexpected: retail cashier jobs aren’t disappearing. For years, experts predicted automation would wipe out checkout workers.

Instead, companies are hiring again. Walmart is converting self-checkout areas back into staffed lanes.

The humans turned out to be harder to replace than anyone thought. And the next time you’re at the store, there might actually be someone to ring you up.

This article was created with AI assistance and human editing.

Read more from this brand:

• Kroger Bet $2.6 Billion on Robot Warehouses. Guess How That Turned Out.
• US Bankruptcies Hit 15-Year High as Tariffs Crush American Businesses
• Yes, You Can Park Your RV at Walmart – But There Are Rules Now