A promised farmworker housing project is testing one coastal city’s priorities

555 Kelly Avenue faces a defining vote

For years, Half Moon Bay officials and housing advocates have discussed creating safer, more stable housing for older farmworkers near downtown. The official 555 Kelly Avenue Affordable Housing Development now faces another major decision after a long path through hearings, approvals, lease talks, and public debate.

The planned five-story building would create 40 affordable units on city-owned land for senior farmworkers, including one manager’s unit. Supporters call it overdue relief, while opponents want voters to decide whether the project should move forward under its current agreements now.

555 Kelly Avenue divides the coast

The 555 Kelly Avenue housing proposal has become a test of what Half Moon Bay values most. The coastal city depends on agricultural workers, yet many struggle to afford housing near the farms, businesses, and families they support.

Project backers say downtown housing would place older residents near stores, buses, health services, and community programs. Critics worry about the building’s height, density, and possible effects on the small-town character that draws residents and visitors to Half Moon Bay.

555 Kelly Avenue carries a promise

The official 555 Kelly Avenue Affordable Housing Development grew out of a city effort launched in 2022 to use public land for affordable housing. Mercy Housing and Ayudando Latinos A Soñar later developed plans focused on older farmworkers with very low incomes.

The project includes 39 affordable apartments, one manager’s unit, and a community support space. Its purpose is simple: give aging agricultural workers a stable home in the community where many have spent years working, raising families, and building local connections.

Why the need became impossible to ignore

Half Moon Bay’s farmworker housing crisis drew national attention after the January 2023 shootings at two mushroom farms. The tragedy also exposed cramped and unsafe living conditions that many agricultural families had quietly endured along the San Mateo County coast.

State leaders then pressed the city to move faster on permanent housing. Supporters say 555 Kelly is one response, offering private apartments and services instead of forcing older workers to keep sharing crowded rooms or living far from their families.

A city-owned lot raises the stakes

The project would rise on land owned by Half Moon Bay at 535 and 555 Kelly Avenue, close to downtown. Using public property can lower development costs, but it brings greater debate because residents expect a voice in how city assets are used.

In May 2026, the council approved a 99-year ground lease with Mercy Housing for $1 per year. That agreement gave the project a key step often needed to secure remaining financing and move closer to construction.

Forty homes meet only a small share

Half Moon Bay faces state housing obligations for the 2023 to 2031 cycle, including a substantial requirement for affordable homes across lower-income categories. The 40 apartments at 555 Kelly would cover only a small part of that state-assigned target.

Even so, the project carries extra weight because it serves a specific group with limited options. Older farmworkers may have low retirement income, health needs, or years of physically demanding work behind them, making stable housing near services important later in life.

Opponents want the public to decide

A group called Let Half Moon Bay Voters Decide gathered signatures seeking a citywide referendum on the lease approval. The group says residents deserve a direct vote on a five-story development that could influence future decisions about height and density downtown.

Supporters see the referendum differently. They argue that repeated votes and hearings have already delayed homes for people in urgent need, and another election could threaten funding, raise costs, or halt development after years of public review.

Fun fact: California voters can challenge some local legislative decisions through the referendum process.

The height debate shapes local fears

The proposed building would be five stories tall, higher than the scale many residents associate with downtown Half Moon Bay. Opponents say approving it could encourage denser projects and change the look and feel of the coastal community.

Supporters note that California density bonus laws can allow extra height when developments provide deeply affordable housing. They also argue that homes near downtown services reduce driving and make life easier for seniors who may no longer feel comfortable traveling long distances.

Millions in funding could be at risk

Recent reporting says Mercy Housing has secured more than $21 million for the project, including about $13 million from California’s Joe Serna Jr. Farmworker Housing Grant Program. Additional financing would still be needed before construction starts.

Affordable housing money often comes with deadlines, rules, and competitive cycles. Long delays can increase labor and material costs or cause grants to expire. Supporters warn that sending the lease to voters or rescinding it completely could make it harder to complete a difficult financing plan.

California takes the city to court

In mid July 2026, California Attorney General Rob Bonta and state housing officials sued Half Moon Bay over its overdue housing element. The city was one of five communities targeted for failing to complete a legally compliant plan on time.

The lawsuit is broader than the 555 Kelly project, but state leaders have cited delays as part of the problem. California wants Half Moon Bay to adopt a compliant housing plan, meet deadlines, and make room for homes across income levels.

Local services make downtown matter

For an older resident, location can matter almost as much as rent. The 555 Kelly site is near downtown destinations, making it easier to reach groceries, transit, health appointments, services, and nonprofit support without a long car trip.

The development would also include a community space connected with Ayudando Latinos A Soñar, known locally as ALAS. That setting could help residents find language assistance, wellness programs, and trusted neighbors, reducing isolation while keeping farmworkers connected to the coastside community.

A bigger housing argument sits underneath

The fight reflects a wider California struggle often described as YIMBY versus NIMBY. One side pushes for more housing in established communities, while the other raises concerns about traffic, design, infrastructure, neighborhood character, or the pace of change.

Half Moon Bay adds coastal rules, limited land, and high construction costs to that familiar debate. The central question is whether local concerns should slow a project serving vulnerable workers, or whether state pressure overrides decisions that residents believe should remain local.

For another California housing update tied to local pushback, neighborhood change, and state pressure, see why a Hollywood project could reshape the debate.

The empty lot keeps telling the story

Whatever officials decide, the vacant Kelly Avenue site shows how slowly affordable housing can move. Planning began years ago, money has been committed, and the need is widely recognized, yet construction has not started and may still be years away.

For farmworkers waiting for stable homes, delays carry a cost. For opponents, the project could permanently reshape downtown. Half Moon Bay must now balance those concerns while answering a question: who gets to live in the community they helped sustain?

For another California housing update tied to conservation concerns, local growth, and protected landscapes, see why a Yosemite border project is facing a fight.

Should affordable housing for farmworkers come first when coastal communities push back? Share your thoughts and drop a comment.

This slideshow was made with AI assistance and human editing.

Read More From This Brand:

• Proposed housing rule faces scrutiny as build-to-rent projects pause
• A major housing boom is putting San Rafael on the edge of big change
• New Hampshire could see changes from new federal housing plans