Connect with us

California

California’s free preschool is putting private daycares out of business

Published

 

on

Preschool teacher leading interactive circle time with children raising hands

Every 4-year-old now gets free preschool

Every 4-year-old in California can now attend transitional kindergarten at a public school for free.

The program hit full rollout this school year after a four-year expansion that Gov. Gavin Newsom signed into law in 2021.

At least 200,000 children are expected to enroll this fall, making it the largest free preschool program in the country.

TK works as a bridge between preschool and kindergarten, with play-based learning, art projects, and small class sizes.

Entrance doorway to child care center

Billions fuel the preschool expansion

The price tag is massive. Newsom nearly tripled state funding for subsidized childcare and early childhood programs, from roughly $5 billion in 2020 to more than $14 billion.

His administration also funded about 130,000 new subsidized childcare spaces for low-income families. TK alone costs the state about $3 billion a year.

New classroom rules now require a 10-to-1 ratio of students to adults, which kicked in this school year.

Kindergarten preschool classroom interior.

Private preschools can’t compete with free

Private preschools and daycares across California are watching their 4-year-olds walk out the door.

Tuition from older kids, who need less hands-on care, usually helps cover the higher cost of caring for infants and toddlers. When those 4-year-olds leave for a free public option, the whole business model falls apart.

Switching to younger children is not simple either.

Providers face new licensing rules, building renovations, and extra staffing costs that many cannot afford.

Decals of children on doors of child care center

Los Angeles County lost 167 preschool centers

A UC Berkeley study from December 2025 found that 167 preschool centers in Los Angeles County closed or let their licenses expire between 2020 and 2024. Those closures wiped out about 12,000 childcare slots.

Researchers tied the losses partly to the growth of free public preschool. In some neighborhoods, families lost more childcare seats than they gained in new TK spots.

Researchers called these areas “pre-K deserts,” where options are shrinking fast.

Female teacher holding flashcard with letter A teaching preschool alphabet

Wealthier families gain the most from TK

The same UC Berkeley study found a striking gap. In LA County’s wealthiest ZIP codes, TK enrollment grew about three times faster than in the poorest ones.

In affluent areas like Brentwood, demand for public preschool jumped about 148% as families ditched private programs costing up to $36,000 a year. In the poorest ZIP codes, enrollment grew only about 50%.

Many low-income families stayed with subsidized centers or relatives, especially where TK ran only half a day.

Empty classroom with chairs and tables at daycare center

California funds TK differently than other states

Most states with universal pre-K let families pick a free program at a public school or a private center. California only funds TK at public schools as its free option.

Other programs like state preschool and Head Start remain limited by income and available slots. That means private providers do not share in the expansion funding.

Advocates say this gap is a big reason so many private centers are struggling to stay open.

Game room in municipal kindergarten with light wooden furniture and learning materials

One preschool owner lost nearly all her students

Shilpa Panech ran Panache Enfants in San Ramon for 13 years, caring for children from 6 months to 6 years old. She watched her 4-year-old enrollment drop from 24 kids to just one.

She looked into expanding infant care but found the staffing and licensing costs too steep. Her family drained savings and took on debt to make payroll.

Last month, she helped her 30 remaining families find other care and closed, removing 72 licensed childcare spots from Contra Costa County.

Interior of child care center

A funding safety net expires in 2026

California let subsidized childcare centers keep their pre-pandemic funding levels even as they lost 4-year-olds. That “hold harmless” protection ends in July 2026.

Advocates and researchers expect another wave of closures once it expires. Each closure does not just remove preschool spots.

Many of these centers also care for infants and toddlers, so when one shuts down, the youngest children lose their spots too.

Father lifting boy from car safety seat and securing him with child safety belt

Half-day TK leaves working parents scrambling

Many TK programs run only about three and a half hours a day, similar to a half-day kindergarten schedule. That is not nearly enough for working parents.

Many districts have not set up enough before-school and after-school care to fill the gap. Some parents stick with private providers that offer full-day care, even though it costs money.

Advocates want districts to partner with private centers to cover the hours TK does not.

Happy female teacher playing hand games with group of little schoolchildren

California needs at least 12,000 more TK teachers

Early Edge California estimates the state is short at least 12,000 qualified TK teachers. The Learning Policy Institute puts the need between about 11,900 and 15,600 new credentialed teachers.

The state created a new TK-through-third-grade teaching credential, and districts are teaming up with colleges to train more educators. Finding classroom assistants has also been tough.

On top of staffing, TK classrooms must include bathrooms, which has forced expensive remodeling and new construction across districts.

Teacher teaching children in daycare

Researchers say the verdict is still out

Some experts say it is too early to know whether TK is reaching new families or just pulling children who would have gone to preschool anyway.

A state official pushed back on the UC Berkeley study, noting that declining birth rates could also explain preschool closures.

About 70% of eligible 4-year-olds are expected to enroll in TK, which means 30% of families are choosing other options. Early research does show TK children tend to perform better in reading and math.

Preschool children and teachers threading colorful beads to create necklaces

Advocates push for fixes before more centers close

Advocates want the state to fund more childcare vouchers so private centers can survive alongside TK. Some propose requiring school districts to partner with private providers for extended care.

Researchers recommend a simpler system that gives families real choices among high-quality programs. For now, families with 4-year-olds have a new free option.

But whether California can expand free preschool without hollowing out the broader childcare system remains an open question.

This article was created with AI assistance and human editing.

Read more from this brand:

John Ghost is a professional writer and SEO director. He graduated from Arizona State University with a BA in English (Writing, Rhetorics, and Literacies). As he prepares for graduate school to become an English professor, he writes weird fiction, plays his guitars, and enjoys spending time with his wife and daughters. He lives in the Valley of the Sun. Learn more about John on Muck Rack.

Trending Posts