Connecticut’s Webb House: where Washington’s stubbornness nearly cost America freedom

Washington and Rochambeau’s Five-Day Yorktown Strategy Meeting

In May 1781, two men sat down in a Connecticut house and changed history. George Washington wanted to attack New York.

French General Rochambeau thought Virginia made more sense.

For five days at the Webb House in Wethersfield, they argued, planned, and finally agreed to join forces first, then pick a target.

When Admiral de Grasse later chose to sail his fleet to Chesapeake Bay, their path was clear. Four months later, Cornwallis surrendered at Yorktown, and America won its freedom.

The south parlor where they hammered out this world-changing plan still stands today, waiting for your visit.

Washington Obsessed Over Retaking New York City

George Washington wanted New York City badly in 1781. He spotted a chance when British General Henry Clinton sent most of his troops south.

With only a small British force left, Washington thought his American troops plus French allies, about 8,300 men total, could take the city.

The British had held New York since 1776, and Washington saw winning it back as both meaningful and strategically important.

French General Had Serious Doubts About Washington’s Plan

Comte de Rochambeau didn’t share Washington’s New York fixation. The French commander believed their 8,300 troops couldn’t break through the city’s strong defenses.

The British had spent five years building forts all over Manhattan.

Rochambeau also worried about ships, knowing Admiral de Grasse’s large vessels couldn’t sail in New York’s shallow waters.

He pushed instead for fighting in Virginia, where French ships could easily move in the deeper Chesapeake Bay.

Two Military Minds Met in a Connecticut Farmhouse

The Webb House in Wethersfield, Connecticut hosted talks that changed history on May 21-22, 1781.

Washington came from his base while Rochambeau traveled from Newport, Rhode Island for their first big strategy meeting. Both brought maps and reports about British positions.

They sat in the farmhouse parlor with their officers, using translators to overcome language barriers. The revolution’s success depended on their ability to agree.

Generals Clashed Over Where to Strike the British

The room grew tense as Washington pushed for attacking New York.

He argued that taking the city would cut the British off from the Hudson River and hurt their war effort badly. Rochambeau pointed to reports showing Lord Cornwallis had left his army exposed in Virginia.

The French general kept talking about the Chesapeake Bay’s deep waters, perfect for naval battles. They disagreed about where the British seemed most vulnerable.

They Found Middle Ground After Hours of Debate

After two days of heated talks, they reached a compromise.

Rochambeau agreed to march his 4,000 French troops from Rhode Island to join Washington’s army along the Hudson. Once together, they would decide which target looked better: New York or Virginia.

Their final choice would mostly depend on where Admiral de Grasse brought his powerful French fleet. This flexible plan kept their alliance strong while keeping options open during the key summer fighting season.

A French Admiral Made the Decision for Them

Admiral de Grasse settled the matter in August 1781 with a letter that changed the war. He told Washington and Rochambeau he planned to sail to Chesapeake Bay, not New York.

The admiral mentioned practical reasons: the deeper waters and better anchoring spots in the Chesapeake suited his 28 warships. He also promised to bring 3,200 more French troops from the Caribbean.

His choice ended Washington’s hopes for a New York campaign and forced a move to Virginia.

Armies Marched South While Fooling the British

Washington and Rochambeau left the New York area in mid-August with 7,000 troops. They marched through New Jersey and Philadelphia toward Virginia with impressive teamwork.

Washington cleverly pretended New York remained his target.

He left soldiers behind to build fake camps and bread ovens near Manhattan and sent false messages he knew the British would catch. Clinton fell for the trick and stayed in New York while the real threat moved south.

Naval Victory Trapped the British Army

De Grasse’s fleet fought a key battle against British Admiral Thomas Graves on September 5, 1781. The ships fired at each other for five days off the Virginia coast in the Battle of the Chesapeake.

The French won, forcing the damaged British fleet to retreat to New York for repairs.

This sea victory created a blockade around Yorktown, where Cornwallis and his 8,000 troops found themselves stuck with no escape by sea.

Allies Surrounded Yorktown With Overwhelming Force

French and American troops circled Yorktown on September 28 with 17,600 men. Engineers started building siege lines and artillery positions using European battle methods.

Heavy cannons moved into firing range as they tightened their grip on Cornwallis. The British commander watched helplessly as his supplies ran low and casualties grew from constant cannon fire.

His men tried digging in, but the allied forces steadily closed in day after day.

Redoubts Fell in a Daring Night Attack

Allied forces stormed two key British defensive positions on October 14 in a bold nighttime assault. Alexander Hamilton led American troops against Redoubt 10 while French soldiers attacked Redoubt 9.

Both positions fell within an hour of fierce hand-to-hand combat.

The capture of these outer defenses allowed Washington and Rochambeau to move their artillery dangerously close to the main British lines.

Cornwallis grew desperate and attempted to ferry his troops across the York River on October 16, but a storm scattered his boats.

The British Surrendered After a Decisive Defeat

Cornwallis asked for surrender terms on October 17, 1781, seeing no path to victory. Two days later, 8,000 British troops laid down their arms in a formal ceremony.

Cornwallis claimed illness and sent his deputy Charles O’Hara to surrender his sword. American independence stood virtually assured after this decisive victory.

The battle that began with a strategic disagreement in a Connecticut farmhouse ended with British soldiers marching between lines of French and American troops while their band played “The World Turned Upside Down.”

Visiting Joseph Webb House, Connecticut

The Joseph Webb House at 211 Main Street in Wethersfield is where Washington and Rochambeau planned the Yorktown campaign that ended the Revolutionary War.

Admission costs $18 for adults, $15 for seniors and students, and $6 for kids 5-12. Guided tours run at 11am, 1pm, and 3pm Tuesday-Saturday, plus 1pm and 3pm Sunday from May-October.

Your tour includes three historic houses, exhibition galleries, and a Colonial Revival garden.

This article was created with AI assistance and human editing.

Read more from this brand:

• This state executed more “witches” than Salem and nobody talks about it
• How a Connecticut epidemic created the modern cemetery
• After Pequot War massacres, one sachem’s desperate deal with English colonists