How 53 Africans turned a murder trial into America’s biggest slavery case at this historic Connecticut landmark

Sengbe Pieh’s Amistad Revolt and Hartford Trial

In 1839, fifty-three Africans broke free on the slave ship Amistad using just a nail and some guts. Led by Sengbe Pieh, they killed the captain and took over, but got caught near Long Island weeks later.

The U.S. Navy hauled them to Connecticut’s Old State House in Hartford, where they faced murder charges. Their lawyer Roger Baldwin fought hard, and the case went all the way to the Supreme Court.

There, former president John Quincy Adams helped win their freedom in 1841. The historic courtroom where this fight for justice began still stands in Hartford today.

Portuguese Slave Hunters Grabbed 53 Africans From Sierra Leone

In February 1839, Portuguese slave hunters kidnapped a large group of Africans from Sierra Leone. Among them was Sengbe Pieh, a 25-year-old rice farmer with a wife and three children.

The kidnappers locked them inside the slave ship Tecora, breaking laws against the slave trade. After a brutal trip across the Atlantic, they reached Cuba.

Spanish plantation owners José Ruiz and Pedro Montez bought 53 of these Africans and loaded them onto the schooner Amistad on June 28, 1839.

The captives wore shackles on their ankles, wrists, and necks, and slept in tight spaces.

A Hidden Nail Became The Key To Freedom

On July 2, 1839, Cinqué used a hidden nail to free himself and other captives from their iron collars during a stormy night. The freed Africans found sugarcane knives on board and fought back under Cinqué’s leadership.

They killed the ship’s captain Ramón Ferrer and the cook Celestino. Two captives died during the fight, and two sailors escaped in a small boat.

The Africans kept the cabin boy Antonio alive along with José Ruiz and Pedro Montez because they needed them to steer the ship back to Africa.

Ship Navigators Tricked The Freed Captives For Months

The Mende people wanted to go home, but navigator Montes fooled them about their direction.

He sailed east during daylight when the Africans could see the sun, but at night he sneakily turned north toward American waters. This trick went on for over two months as the ship drifted along the North American coast.

Several New York pilot boats met La Amistad during this time. The pilot-boat Blossom gave them water and bread on August 21, 1839.

More than a dozen Africans died from sickness and harsh conditions before reaching land.

US Navy Grabbed The Ship Near Long Island

The Amistad reached Long Island, New York on August 24, 1839, where the USS Washington caught the ship.

Lieutenant Thomas Gedney took control of the schooner, its cargo, and everyone on board, bringing them to Connecticut.

Officials quickly freed plantation owners Ruiz and Montez while throwing the Africans in jail on murder charges. Just five days later, on August 29, Sengbe Pieh stood in chains before a U.S. District Court.

This hearing took place on a navy ship in New London harbor, starting a historic legal battle.

Courtroom Drama Unfolded At Hartford’s Old State House

The Amistad Trial started at Hartford’s Old State House on September 19, 1839. The U.S. Circuit Court held early hearings about who should handle the case.

Between September 19 and 23, lawyers fighting for the Mende sought legal papers while the captives sat in New Haven jail. Judge Andrew T. Judson put the matter to a grand jury.

The hearings reached an important finding: since the Africans’ revolt happened in open waters, American courts couldn’t try them for mutiny and murder.

Lawyers Found African Interpreters Who Changed Everything

During two months in Hartford, defense lawyer Roger Sherman Baldwin built the case that would reach the U.S. Supreme Court.

A breakthrough came when abolitionists found James Covey and Charles Pratt, sailors from West Africa’s Mende region who spoke the captives’ language.

These interpreters let the Africans finally tell their stories in their own words.

For the first time, abolitionists learned exactly how the captives were kidnapped and could share these personal stories with the public.

The second round of the trial started in Hartford from November 19-20, but got pushed to January 7, 1840.

Judge Declared The Africans Were Born Free People

At the US Circuit Court trial in Hartford, the judge threw out murder charges against the Mende.

Then in January 1840, the district court judge made a key ruling: the Africans had every right to fight their illegal capture and were free people.

His decision stated they were “natives of Africa and were born free and ever since have been and still of right are free and not slaves. ” He ordered them returned to Africa.

The court said the Africans could legally use force to gain their freedom since they were fighting against unlawful imprisonment.

President Van Buren Tried To Send Them Back To Cuba

President Martin Van Buren wanted to send the Africans to Cuba to please Spain, but the court’s decision stopped his plan. The U.S. Government felt pressure from Spain and worried about making Southern states angry, so they appealed to the Supreme Court.

The U.S. Circuit Court backed the lower court’s decision before the Supreme Court agreed to hear the case in January 1841.

Abolitionists visited former president John Quincy Adams at his home on October 27, 1840. They convinced the 73-year-old Adams, who hadn’t argued a case in years, to join the defense team.

Former President Adams Stood Up For The Captives’ Rights

On February 22, 1841, U.S. Attorney General Henry D. Gilpin started arguments, claiming the Court couldn’t rule against Spanish papers that listed the Africans as property.

Adams felt very nervous and asked his colleague Roger Baldwin to make opening statements. When his turn came, Adams spoke for four and a half hours across two days.

He talked about the humanity and natural rights of the captives.

Adams argued that the secret landing in Havana and unlawful sale were all parts of one big illegal plan from the start.

Supreme Court Ruled Africans Had Right To Fight For Freedom

The Supreme Court announced its decision on March 9, 1841, with only one justice disagreeing. They ruled the Africans had been illegally enslaved and had a natural right to fight for their freedom.

This verdict surprised many, since seven of the nine justices came from Southern states. Justice Joseph Story delivered the opinion that freed the remaining thirty-five survivors.

The Court backed the lower court ruling and ordered the release of the Mende, but wouldn’t pay to send them back to Africa. After winning, Adams wrote to Baldwin sharing the good news.

Thirty-Five Survivors Finally Sailed Home To Sierra Leone

Supporters arranged housing for the Africans in Farmington, Connecticut, and raised money for their journey home.

Private donations paid for their safe return, and in November 1841 they left America aboard a ship called the Gentleman bound for West Africa.

In January 1842, thirty-five survivors who wanted to go back to Africa, along with American Christian missionaries, arrived in Sierra Leone. Some of the freed Africans helped start a Christian mission in Sierra Leone.

Most, including Cinqué, traveled further inland to find their original homes and families after their three-year ordeal that changed American law and highlighted the injustice of slavery.

Visiting Old State House, Connecticut

You can visit the Old State House at 800 Main Street in Hartford to learn about the Amistad trials in the same courtroom where the West Africans fought for their freedom.

Adult admission costs $8, with discounts for seniors and students at $4. The building is open Tuesday through Saturday from 12-5 PM and Thursday until 8 PM.

Take a guided tour to hear about the historic case and explore the restored Senate Chamber.

This article was created with AI assistance and human editing.

Read more from this brand:

• America’s first boarding school for black girls – and its violent end in 1830s Connecticut
• The nine-month strike that split Willimantic, Connecticut for 50 years
• America’s first president wasn’t Washington – and he learned law from stolen books