Why New Haven Locals Pronounce Their Famous Pizza “Ah-BEETZ” & More Facts About This Legend

The Legend of the Apizza

If you’re in New Haven, it’s apizza. Born in the coal ovens of Italian immigrants, this charred and chewy Connecticut pie sparked a style that pizza lovers now chase across the country. From the right way to say ‘apizza’ to the rules of ordering, here’s the real story behind New Haven’s famous pies.

How the Unique Name Came About

New Haven-style pizza goes by “apizza” (pronounced “ah-BEETZ”) thanks to Southern Italian immigrants who moved to the area between 1910-1920. This way of saying “pizza” stuck around and became part of the city’s heritage.

Vintage signs from the 1920s throughout Wooster Square still show this unique spelling. When locals order, they stress the second syllable with a hand gesture that’s been used the same way for almost 100 years, even while other Italian words changed to sound more American.

The Coal-Fired Oven Difference

The secret weapon behind New Haven pizza is the coal-fired oven. These ovens create a dry heat that makes the crust super crispy in a short time.

Unlike Neapolitan pizzas that cook for about a minute at very high heat, New Haven pies cook a bit slower at temperatures above 650°F. Some ovens can reach 1,000°F, much hotter than wood-burning ovens that only hit about 600-700°F.

The intense heat seals in flavors and creates that signature char. Dating back to the 1920s, these ovens use anthracite coal instead of bituminous coal, which gives off less smoke and more steady heat.

Three Rival Pizzerias Started The Apizza Tradition

New Haven pizza can’t be talked about without mentioning “The Holy Trinity” of pizzerias: Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana (started in 1925), Sally’s Apizza (started in 1938), and Modern Apizza (started in 1934). Some people add Grand Apizza to make it “The Big 4.” Frank Pepe came through Ellis Island in 1909 without knowing English but determined to succeed.

His nephew Sally Consiglio opened his competing restaurant just 198 feet down Wooster Street. Modern Apizza, first called Tony’s Apizza, was started by Ignazio Camposano.

Together, these pizza places have served more than 10 million pizzas since they opened their doors.

The Classic Tomato Pie

Ask for a “plain” pizza in New Haven, and you won’t get cheese—at least not mozzarella. What comes out of the oven is crust topped with oregano, tomato sauce, and just a sprinkle of grated pecorino romano cheese.

Sometimes called a “tomato pie,” this basic version shows off the crust’s quality. Mozzarella isn’t standard—it’s just another topping you can add.

This simple approach dates back to when Italian immigrants had limited ingredients in the 1920s and refrigeration wasn’t common. When Frank Pepe first sold his tomato pies, they cost only 25 cents each.

Clam Pizza Was Born From A Bar Appetizer

One of New Haven’s most famous pizza creations is the white clam pie. Frank Pepe and Ignacio Camposano (who later started Modern Apizza) are often credited with creating this unusual combo.

A traditional clam pie comes with fresh shucked clams, garlic, oregano, olive oil, and pecorino romano—without sauce or mozzarella. This pizza started in the 1940s when Pepe was already serving littleneck clams as a bar appetizer and decided to try them on pizza.

The clams come only from Rhode Island, delivered fresh every day. New Haven pizza experts insist on freshly shucked clams, never canned or frozen ones.

Dark Spots On The Crust Add Smoky Barbecue Flavor

First-time visitors often think New Haven pizza is burnt because of the dark spots on the crust. Locals quickly explain: “It’s not burnt, it’s charred.”

These black marks happen because of the coal ovens and thin crust, and they add a specific smoky taste that’s been compared to barbecue. The char results from a specific reaction between proteins and sugars called the Maillard reaction.

Expert pizza makers know exactly when to take the pizza out of the oven based on subtle changes in the char’s color.

No Two Slices Look The Same In A New Haven Pie

New Haven pizzas come large, never perfectly round, and cut into at least 16 slices. The thin, often oval-shaped crust gets its uneven form because the dough is stretched by hand instead of rolled out.

Pizza makers use large scissors to cut the pies rather than wheel cutters. A typical New Haven pizza measures about 18 inches across at its widest point, making it bigger than what you’d find in New York.

Because of the pizza’s shape, each slice ends up a slightly different size and shape from the others.

Say Mootz if You Want Cheese

In New Haven, mozzarella goes by a nickname: “mootz.” When ordering, you need to ask for it specifically—even on a red sauce pizza—or your pie will come without it.

The term “mootz” started in the 1930s among New Haven’s Italian community and reflects the Southern Italian pronunciation. When added to a pizza, “mootz” traditionally goes under the toppings, not on top like in other pizza styles.

This difference might seem small, but it’s part of what makes New Haven pizza unique.

Bakeries Turned Into The First Pizzerias In 1915

Before dedicated pizza shops existed in New Haven, bakeries made and sold the first pies. Francesco Scalzo and Ignazio Camposano opened bakeries around 1915, with Camposano starting a restaurant that likely sold pizza in 1924—before Frank Pepe’s famous 1925 opening.

Pepe himself started by selling coal-fired pizzas from a pushcart in Wooster Square before opening his restaurant. The bakers changed their bread ovens to reach higher temperatures. Early pizza makers would bake bread in the morning hours and switch to making pizza in the afternoon, using the same ovens for both.

Wooster Street Hosts Two Famous Pizzerias 198 Feet Apart

As pizza grew more popular, shops opened throughout New Haven but became centered in Little Italy on Wooster Street. When Frank Pepe opened his pizzeria on this street and his nephew Sal Consiglio started Sally’s just two blocks away, they created both a famous rivalry and New Haven’s pizza legacy.

Customers line up outside both places regardless of bad weather. Frank Pepe’s original spot, now called “The Spot,” still exists just behind and to the left of the current Pepe’s location. Since 1972, Wooster Street has hosted annual pizza contests that draw crowds from across the Northeast.

Fresh Tomato Pies Appear Only During Summer Months

During summer, pizza lovers can get a seasonal treat: the Fresh Tomato Pie. This special pizza comes topped with fresh tomatoes, garlic, mozzarella, and olive oil instead of sauce.

Available only from July through September when tomatoes are in season, this pie features tomatoes from Connecticut farms within 20 miles of New Haven. The tomatoes get sliced paper-thin and slightly dried before being placed on the pizza.

This seasonal favorite started during a tomato sauce shortage in 1945 and became a tradition that pizza fans look forward to each year.

Pizza Bones

New Haven pizza fans have their own language, including the term “bones” for the pizza crust that doesn’t get eaten. This slang started in the 1950s when factory workers had short lunch breaks.

Regular customers at Pepe’s get called “boneheads” because they collect leftover crusts. Unlike New York style where folding the slice is common, New Haven pizza is eaten flat, starting from the tip and working toward the “bone.” According to tradition, it’s good manners to leave at least one “bone” on your plate when finished.

New Haven Pizza Techniques Spread To Tokyo And London

New Haven-style pizza has gained fans around the world, especially in the United Kingdom. Near London, in St. Albans, Gracey’s Pizza makes pies directly inspired by New Haven.

The style has even returned to New York with places like Lala’s Brooklyn Apizza. Tokyo now has three New Haven-style pizzerias that import coal from Pennsylvania to get the right taste.

Cooking schools in Italy teach New Haven methods alongside traditional Neapolitan techniques. The Culinary Institute of America added specific New Haven pizza classes in 2019.

Pepe’s famous recipe has been translated into 14 languages as the style keeps spreading globally.

Read More from This Brand:

• Every PEZ Candy in America Comes From This Single Connecticut Factory You Can Tour Today
• If You’re an 80’s Connecticut Kid, You Definitely Miss These 10 Foods
• These 12 Outdoor Spots in Connecticut Are Almost Too Beautiful To Be Real