Spain’s religious purge of French Huguenots at Florida’s Matanzas Inlet in 1565

The Huguenot Martyrs of Matanzas Inlet

Fort Matanzas National Monument in Florida marks where 245 French Protestants chose death over betraying their faith.

In 1565, Spanish Admiral Pedro Menéndez de Avilés hunted down French Huguenots who had come seeking religious freedom in the New World.

A hurricane wrecked their ships near Cape Canaveral, leaving survivors stranded and starving. When Menéndez found them at Matanzas Inlet, he demanded they convert to Catholicism or die.

They refused. He executed them in groups of ten, sparing only a few Catholics and useful craftsmen. The inlet’s name still means “slaughters” in Spanish.

This is the story behind one of America’s earliest religious massacres and where you can visit the monument today.

Spanish King Orders Removal of “Heretics” in Florida

King Philip II of Spain got mad when he found out French Protestants built Fort Caroline on his claimed Florida land in 1564.

He worried these Huguenots might attack his treasure ships sailing near Florida.

Philip, a strict Catholic, saw these Protestants as dangerous heretics. He told Admiral Pedro Menéndez to destroy the French colony and take control of Florida.

Jean Ribault left France in May 1565 with over 600 soldiers and settlers on seven ships to bring supplies to Fort Caroline.

St. Augustine Becomes Spain’s First Florida Foothold

Menéndez reached Florida in August 1565 with 800 Spanish soldiers, sailors, and settlers on several ships.

He started building St.Augustine on September 8, naming it after the day’s saint. His men quickly put up walls and defenses, expecting a French attack soon.

Menéndez sent his big flagship San Pelayo to Hispaniola because it couldn’t fit through St. Augustine’s shallow inlet. The Spanish commander set up his remaining ships and got his men ready to fight Ribault’s forces.

A Hurricane Wrecks Ribault’s Attack Plans

Ribault tried to strike first on September 10, 1565, sailing south with his four biggest warships to hit the Spanish settlement.

But a powerful hurricane hit the coast on September 11, pushing all of Ribault’s ships far south of their target.

The storm smashed three ships to pieces near Cape Canaveral, while his flagship La Trinité got stuck on a sandbar.

Hundreds of French soldiers who made it to shore began walking north toward Fort Caroline, wet, hungry, and without weapons.

Spanish Forces Attack Fort Caroline During the Storm

Menéndez saw his chance and marched 40 miles north through swamps during the hurricane with 50-70 soldiers.

His men launched a surprise attack at dawn on September 20, 1565, catching Fort Caroline almost empty of defenders.

The Spanish killed 132 of the 240 French people there.

René de Laudonnière and artist Jacques LeMoyne escaped with about 40 others on waiting ships and sailed back to France.

Menéndez renamed the captured fort “San Mateo.

Shipwrecked Frenchmen Get Trapped at an Inlet

Local Timucuan Indians told Menéndez about white men walking north along the beach.

On September 28, 1565, Spanish scouts found 127 French survivors stuck at what we now call Matanzas Inlet, 14 miles south of St. Augustine.

These tired Frenchmen were trapped on the wrong side of the water with no way to cross. They had lost most of their weapons and food in the shipwreck and faced starvation.

Menéndez showed up with his soldiers and arranged them to look like a larger force.

Desperate Survivors Face an Impossible Choice

Using a French prisoner as a translator, Menéndez told the survivors he had destroyed Fort Caroline.

He described how he killed their friends at the fort but offered no promises about what would happen to them. Weak from days without proper food or shelter, the 127 French survivors gave up and surrendered.

Spanish boats carried the prisoners across the inlet in groups of ten with their hands tied behind their backs. Father Francisco López asked Menéndez to spare any Catholics among the French.

Faith Becomes a Matter of Life or Death

Menéndez asked each French prisoner a simple but deadly question: would they accept Catholicism or stay Protestant? Most of the French refused to give up their Huguenot faith even though they knew they would die.

Only 16 men lived: a few who said they were Catholic, some Breton sailors who were forced to join the trip, and four skilled workers needed in St. Augustine.

Spanish soldiers took the other 111 Frenchmen behind sand dunes and stabbed them to death. They left the bodies on the beach.

Ribault Follows His Men to the Same Deadly Trap

Jean Ribault and about 150 more survivors from his flagship continued walking north along the coast. They reached Matanzas Inlet on October 12, 1565, and found signs of the earlier killing.

Though they learned what happened to their friends, Ribault and his tired men were stuck in the same hopeless spot.

Spanish scouts quickly spotted this new group and reported back. Menéndez returned to the inlet with his soldiers, ready for another round of surrender.

The French Commander Makes His Final Decision

Ribault thought his starving men might get better treatment, so he agreed to surrender his remaining force. About 200 of his men didn’t trust the Spanish and slipped away.

The French admiral and 134 followers gave themselves up to Menéndez, who again promised nothing about their safety.

Ribault faced death calmly, singing a psalm and telling Menéndez that he would soon have to answer to God himself.

Just like before, Spanish soldiers took the tied-up prisoners across the inlet.

Refusing to Convert Seals Their Fate

Menéndez again gave the French prisoners a choice between becoming Catholic or dying. All but about 16 of Ribault’s men refused to abandon their Protestant faith.

Spanish soldiers killed 134 Frenchmen behind the dunes, including Ribault himself. The few who lived included several musicians, mechanics, and those who claimed to be Catholic.

The inlet got its permanent name “Matanzas,” which means “slaughters” in Spanish, from these two massacres that happened just weeks apart.

A King Approves the Bloodshed

King Philip II read Menéndez’s report about killing 245 French Protestant “heretics” and wrote back: “As to those he has killed he has done well.”

Spain kept control of Florida for the next 235 years after wiping out French competition. The massacre ended any organized French attempts to settle in the southeastern part of North America.

Fort Matanzas, the Matanzas River, and the surrounding area still carry Spanish names that remind us of this religious persecution where hundreds chose death over denying their faith.

Visiting Fort Matanzas National Monument, Florida

Fort Matanzas National Monument at 8635 A1A South in St. Augustine tells the story of 245 French Huguenots who died rather than give up their Protestant faith in 1565.

The park opens 9am to 5:30pm daily except holidays. Free ferries to the fort run Thursday through Monday at scheduled times.

You need ferry passes from the visitor center same day only, and they usually run out by 11am on busy days. Some weekends feature weapon firing demonstrations.

This article was created with AI assistance and human editing.

Read more from this brand:

• Spanish conquistadors wiped out Tampa Bay’s ancient Native American civilizations in 150 years of torture and disease
• The white flag betrayal that doomed Seminole chief Osceola
• The 17th-century Florida fortress that took 300 years of attacks and never fell once