This Indianapolis cemetery remembers the Civil War’s most tragic identity theft

Camp Morton’s 1,616 Nameless Confederate Dead

Camp Morton held 9,000 Confederate prisoners in a space meant for 3,000. Packed into dirt-floor barracks, disease ran wild.

After the war, their bodies moved to Greenlawn Cemetery, but soon had to move again for railroad tracks. In this rush, all names got lost.

By 1931, the 1,616 remains were packed into ten boxes and buried at Crown Hill Cemetery. Sixty years passed before a monument finally listed their names.

Over 1,700 men died there, many just boys in rags. The Confederate Mound in Section 32 now tells a story of forgotten men who never made it home.

Trains Brought the First Confederate Prisoners to Indianapolis in 1862

The first Confederate prisoners rolled into Indianapolis by train on February 22, 1862. Within three days, 3,700 men arrived from battles at Fort Donelson and Shiloh.

Many looked half-dead, wearing carpet squares instead of real uniforms.

The Union Army kept these prisoners in old horse, cattle, and pig barns at the former Indiana State Fairgrounds, now called Camp Morton.

Indianapolis locals first saw these captured soldiers as confused young men who might change their minds about the war if shown some kindness.

Overcrowding Turned Camp Morton into a Nightmare

Camp Morton quickly packed in too many men.

Built for about 3,000 prisoners, it soon held 5,000 crammed into just 4.5 acres. Men slept wherever they could, often in animal stalls with dirt floors covered in straw.

Each prisoner got roughly 80 cubic feet of space in poorly aired buildings. The camp’s water got dirty with sewage as more men arrived.

Sickness spread quickly through the crowded rooms. Guards struggled to keep order as things got worse.

Death Became a Daily Occurrence at the Prison Camp

March 1862 brought a shocking 144 deaths at Camp Morton in that single month. About 50 men died each month, with the worst months seeing 133 deaths.

Pneumonia killed the most prisoners, followed by diarrhea, dysentery, and malaria that spread through the packed barracks.

By the time the camp closed, around 1,763 Confederate prisoners had died there, a 20% death rate. The small hospital couldn’t handle all the sick men.

Winter Months Brought Unbearable Suffering to Prisoners

The winter of 1864-1865 brought the worst suffering to Camp Morton. Between December and March, 373 prisoners died and almost 1,200 ended up in the hospital.

Camp Morton ranked third highest in deaths among all Union prison camps during these brutal winter months.

By August 1864, the camp had set up 224 hospital tents for 1,340 patients. Stories spread that both guards and prisoners froze to death in Midwest winters.

Greenlawn Cemetery Became the First Resting Place for the Confederate Dead

Workers first buried the Confederate dead in trenches at Camp Morton before moving them to Greenlawn Cemetery after the war.

The U.S. government bought five sections of Greenlawn just for these Confederate reburials. Workers placed wooden markers with ID numbers at each grave, matching names kept in paper records.

The Confederate section sat along the Vandalia railroad tracks. Some families came to claim their loved ones’ bodies, but most of the dead stayed in Indianapolis soil.

The Government Moved Union Soldiers but Left Confederates Behind

In October 1866, the federal government hired undertaker William Weaver to move 712 Union soldiers from Greenlawn to the new Crown Hill National Cemetery.

By November, 707 Union bodies moved to their new resting place. The Confederate dead stayed behind at Greenlawn, which already started falling apart.

After some families claimed their relatives’ remains, 1,616 Confederate bodies stayed in Indianapolis with no one to speak for them.

While Union graves got regular care, the Confederate section began to rot.

Railroad Expansion Erased Individual Identities in the 1870s

The first big disruption came in 1870 when workers moved the Confederate remains deeper into Greenlawn Cemetery for railroad expansion.

The Vandalia Railroad wanted to build an engine house and more tracks right where many Confederate graves sat. Workers dug up the bodies and reburied them in a mass grave elsewhere in Greenlawn.

Within five years, these same bodies moved yet again. During these moves, the wooden markers got mixed up or lost, and the paper records became useless.

Greenlawn Cemetery Fell into Shocking Disrepair

The Indianapolis Sun painted a grim picture on December 11, 1889, calling Greenlawn “one of the most run-down cemeteries in the state.”

The area around the cemetery turned into an industrial zone filled with noise from trains and awful smells from nearby businesses.

Grave robbing became common as medical schools paid people to dig up fresh bodies for anatomy lessons. The city finally closed Greenlawn to new burials in 1890, but the damage was done.

A Monument Rose as the Cemetery Crumbled Around It

The U.S. government sent Colonel William Elliot to Indianapolis in 1906 to find the Confederate mass grave at Greenlawn.

In 1912, workers put up the Confederate Soldiers and Sailors Monument at Greenlawn to mark the spot where the 1,616 prisoners lay.

By the late 1910s, almost nothing remained of the once-busy cemetery except this monument standing in “a remote corner of the old burying ground.”

In 1928, the city moved the monument to Garfield Park.

The Final Move Scattered Remains Across Multiple Boxes

Industrial growth around Greenlawn Cemetery forced one last move in 1931.

Workers dug up the 1,616 Confederate remains and placed them into ten large boxes for burial at Crown Hill Cemetery.

This final move meant each prisoner moved at least twice, some three times since their death. The worst part came during this last transfer – each man’s remains weren’t kept together but got mixed with others.

Any hope of identifying individual remains vanished completely.

Names Finally Returned to the Forgotten Soldiers After 128 Years

On October 27, 1931, workers reburied the ten boxes holding the 1,616 Confederate prisoners at Crown Hill’s Section 32.

Two years later, a new 6-foot granite monument went up over the Confederate Mound with the simple words “Remains of 1616 Unknown Confederate Soldiers.”

The dead remained nameless for decades more until 1989, when two Indianapolis police officers started pushing to properly mark the graves.

Their work paid off in 1993 when ten bronze plaques listing all 1,616 names finally went up at the site. After 128 years, these men regained their identities, though their individual remains can never be separated again.

Visiting Crown Hill Cemetery, Indiana

Crown Hill Cemetery at 700 West 38th Street in Indianapolis holds the final resting place of 1,616 Confederate prisoners who died at Camp Morton between 1862 and 1865.

You can visit the cemetery grounds for free daily from 8am-8pm April through September and 8am-6pm October through March.

Civil War guided tours run on weekends from May through October, while Heritage Foundation tours need advance online booking. Pick up maps at the main gate.

This article was created with AI assistance and human editing.

Read more from this brand:

• How brutal executions outside Fort Sackville broke British morale and secured the Northwest Territory for America in 1779
• Replacing white waitresses with Black men nearly destroyed four Indiana communities
• The national park trapped by some of the most toxic industrial sites in the USA