How a pregnant Cape Cod woman became the “Witch of Wellfleet” after her pirate lover’s shipwreck

The Wreck of the Whydah and the Legend of the Witch of Wellfleet

Cape Cod’s beaches hide America’s most famous pirate shipwreck and its tragic love story. In 1715, “Black Sam” Bellamy fell for local woman Maria Hallett, then sailed off to plunder Caribbean ships.

He captured the treasure-laden Whydah in 1717 and headed back to Cape Cod, possibly to reunite with her.

But Hallett’s baby had died, the town cast her out, and on April 26, 1717, a violent storm drove Bellamy’s ship onto Wellfleet’s sandbars. All but two crew members drowned.

Legend says Hallett watched from the cliffs as her lover perished, and locals still claim her ghost haunts these shores.

Here’s the full story behind this shipwreck that became America’s greatest pirate treasure discovery.

Young Sailor Bellamy Met His Cape Cod Sweetheart

Sam Bellamy showed up in Eastham around 1714-1715, likely visiting family in the area. The 25-year-old English sailor had just finished his time in the Royal Navy and came to Cape Cod looking to make money.

He soon caught the eye of Maria “Goody” Hallett, a pretty 15-year-old blonde who worked at a local bar. They fell in love fast, but her family looked down on the broke sailor.

Before leaving, Bellamy made her a promise: he’d come back rich enough to marry her properly.

Love Left Her With Child And Community Scorn

Bellamy left Cape Cod with his friend Paulsgrave Williams to hunt Spanish treasure in Florida. After he took off, Maria found out she was pregnant, causing a huge scandal in their strict Puritan town.

Though girls could legally marry at 11 back then, getting pregnant without being married first brought deep shame. Her well-off family couldn’t stand the damage to their name.

The community turned against Maria, forcing her to live alone in a small hut by the shore, cut off from everyone.

Her Baby’s Death Brought Witchcraft Whispers

Maria gave birth by herself in her little beach hut, but the baby died soon after. Some say it suffocated in straw, others think it froze, while some believe it died naturally.

The town arrested Maria and charged her with killing her baby, which could get her hanged in colonial times. Justice Joseph Doane locked her up in Barnstable Jail while folks started calling her cursed.

Rumors of witchcraft spread through town. Her father reportedly paid officials to free her, but she still couldn’t come home and got sent to live near the Wellfleet cliffs in an area locals called “Lucifer Land.

From Failed Treasure Hunter To Pirate King

When Bellamy couldn’t find Spanish gold in Florida, he and Williams joined pirate Benjamin Hornigold’s crew.

The men soon got tired of Hornigold’s leadership and picked Bellamy as their new captain, loving his fair treatment and charm. Bellamy ran his ship like “Robin Hood’s Men,” often letting captured crews go unharmed.

In just over a year, his gang took 53 ships along the East Coast and Caribbean, gathering more loot than any pirate of his time. Sailors called him the “Prince of Pirates” as his fame grew.

The Prize Ship That Sealed His Fate

In late February 1717, Bellamy spotted the Whydah Galley sailing between Cuba and Hispaniola. This 300-ton English slave ship had just sold 312 enslaved people and carried gold, indigo, ivory, and other goods.

After chasing it for three days, Bellamy fired one warning shot, and Captain Lawrence Prince gave up quickly.

Bellamy moved to the Whydah, added more than 30 cannons below deck and stored 4.5 tons of treasure in 180 bags. The ship could sail at 13 knots, making it the most feared pirate vessel in American waters.

A Fateful Journey North To Find His Love

In April 1717, Bellamy sailed the treasure-filled Whydah up the American coast. He kept raiding ships along the way, with his vessel now carrying loot from over 50 captured ships.

Many think he headed toward Provincetown Harbor hoping to reunite with Maria Hallett. His friend Paulsgrave Williams commanded another ship, the Mary Anne, and split off to visit family in Rhode Island.

On April 26, 1717, near Chatham, Massachusetts, the Whydah approached a wall of gray fog warning of bad weather ahead.

Midnight Storm Turned Deadly For Treasure Ship

Just after midnight on April 26, 1717, a violent nor’easter hit the Whydah with hurricane-force winds reaching 70 mph.

Cold Arctic air from Canada crashed into warm tropical air from the Caribbean, creating massive 30 to 40-foot waves. The ship sat low in the water, weighed down by its huge load of stolen treasure.

The crew, possibly drunk from Madeira wine they’d recently taken, struggled to control the ship as conditions got worse. The Whydah found itself pushed toward the hidden sandbars of Wellfleet with no escape route.

Sixteen Feet Of Water Claimed 144 Lives

At 12:15 AM, the Whydah crashed bow-first into a sandbar just 500 feet from shore in only 16 feet of water. The impact snapped the mainmast like a twig, and huge waves started washing over the deck.

The heavy ship, loaded with cannons and treasure, got pulled into deeper 30-foot water and flipped over within minutes.

Thomas Davis, a Welsh carpenter forced into piracy, later told officials the ship broke apart by morning.

Of the 146 people aboard, including Bellamy and his crew, only two men lived: Davis and 16-year-old Miskito pilot John Julian.

She Searched The Beach For Her Lost Love

Over the next few days, 102 bodies washed up on Wellfleet’s beaches. The town coroner buried them in a mass grave.

Local stories claim Maria Hallett watched the wreck from the bluffs, some saying she yelled curses at the storm for taking her lover.

She supposedly walked among the dead bodies on the beach, looking for Bellamy but never found him. People reported seeing her wandering the shoreline, screaming and crying at all the death.

The spot where she lived got nicknamed “Lucifer Land,” “Satan’s Harvest,” or “Devil’s Pasture” in local tales.

Tales Of A Heartbroken Witch Haunted Cape Cod

Two different stories about Maria spread after the wreck.

Some claimed she used witchcraft to call up the storm to destroy Bellamy for leaving her pregnant and alone. Others saw her as a heartbroken woman who lost her mind after watching her lover die.

Villagers supposedly chased her with torches and pitchforks into White Cedar Swamp, where some believe she died.

She became known as “The Witch of Wellfleet,” and folks said her ghost still walks the dunes on stormy nights, forever searching for Bellamy among the waves.

Treasure Stayed Hidden For Nearly Three Centuries

Nine survivors from the wrecked ships got caught and tried for piracy in Boston in October 1717. Six were found guilty and hanged on November 15, 1717, after confessing to Puritan minister Cotton Mather.

Colonial Governor Samuel Shute sent mapmaker Cyprian Southack to get the treasure, but he found 200 locals already picking through the wreckage.

Most of the 4.5 tons of gold, silver, and valuables stayed buried under shifting sands for 267 years.

In 1984, underwater explorer Barry Clifford found the Whydah’s remains, making it the only fully confirmed Golden Age pirate shipwreck ever found.

Visiting Wydah Pirate Museum in West Yarmouth, MA

The Whydah Pirate Museum at 674 Route 28 in West Yarmouth brings the legendary pirate ship’s story to life.

Open daily 10am to 4pm (last entry 3:30pm), admission costs $18 for adults, $14 for kids 5-15, and $16 for seniors.

You can explore a 110-foot ship replica with costumed figures, touch real pirate treasure, and watch conservators work on artifacts.

Guided tours help you learn about the tragic shipwreck and Cape Cod’s supernatural folklore.

This article was created with AI assistance and human editing.

Read more from this brand:

• How 8,000 New England farm daughters became the nation’s first independent working women at Lowell’s Mill
• The Revolutionary War privateer king who made Salem richer than Boston with captured British ships
• The Mendi Bible sits in Massachusetts as proof of America’s most powerful slavery court case