The White House wedding that drove one Adams brother to suicide

Two Adams Brothers’ Battle for One Woman

The White House holds many secrets, but few as scandalous as the love triangle that destroyed the Adams family in 1828.

Mary Catherine Hellen moved in with President John Quincy Adams after her father died, captivating all three Adams sons.

She got engaged to the eldest, George Washington Adams, then married his brother John instead in a private White House ceremony. The betrayal sent George into alcoholism and depression.

He jumped overboard from a steamship and drowned at twenty-eight.

Here’s the full story of this family tragedy, plus how to visit the Adams family home where it all began.

A Young Orphan Moved Into the Adams Home in 1817

Mary Catherine Hellen came to live with John Quincy Adams and his family on F Street in November 1817. The 11-year-old girl moved in after her father Walter Hellen, a tobacco dealer, died in 1815.

She brought two enslaved people, Holzey and Rachel Clark, who she got from her father’s estate.

John Quincy Adams wrote in his diary that “my wife brought home with her Mary Hellen her eldest sister’s daughter, whom she takes to live with us. ” Mary was born in 1806 in Washington, DC.

The pretty, strong-willed girl soon caught the eye of all three Adams sons.

Charles Francis Fell For His Cousin First

Charles Francis Adams, born in 1807, was the youngest and most level-headed Adams brother. As teens living in the same house, Charles and Mary grew close.

Their bond went beyond normal cousin feelings, with Charles later saying Mary “introduced him to the delights of the flesh” during their teen romance.

The quiet, bookish Charles fell completely for Mary during their early years together. Their romance was short-lived, though.

Mary got bored with the youngest Adams brother and aimed higher. Charles later called her “one of the most moody women ever formed in a moody race.

George Wrote Poetry For His New Fiancée

Mary dumped Charles for his older brother George Washington Adams, the oldest son and likely family heir. George was born in 1801 in Berlin when his father worked as a diplomat.

The tender-hearted and poetic George fell hard for Mary, writing her love poems and asking her to marry him. The family hoped this engagement would boost the troubled Harvard graduate’s confidence.

George and Mary put off their wedding until he finished school.

The match seemed good at first, with George showing real love for his fiancée and Mary seeming to love him back.

The White House Became Home To A Love Triangle

John Quincy Adams won the presidency in 1825, changing where and how the family lived. His middle son John had gotten kicked out of Harvard, so he came to Washington to work as his father’s helper.

Mary Hellen moved with the family to the White House, as many families did back then. Living together in the president’s house created new relationships among the young people.

Time apart from George didn’t make Mary love him more. Instead, the distance let another Adams son catch her eye.

The White House, meant to be John Quincy’s greatest success, soon became the place where his family fell apart.

John Stole His Brother’s Fiancée Under The Presidential Roof

John Adams II, the proud, sarcastic middle brother born in 1803, started chasing Mary. Though he liked drinking, John seemed to handle his liquor better than his older brother.

John and Mary started a romance while she was still engaged to George. The President and First Lady knew their oldest son would be crushed by this betrayal.

John decided to take Mary away from George and won her heart. This betrayal started the family’s downfall.

John had already let his father down by getting thrown out of Harvard for joining the 1823 student riots.

The Blue Room Hosted A Secret Wedding Ceremony

On February 25, 1828, Mary Catherine Hellen, 22, married John Adams II, 25, in a small ceremony at the White House. The wedding took place in what we now call the Blue Room.

Louisa Adams didn’t like the match but thought the love-struck young couple needed to marry. She quickly set up a small White House wedding.

The hurt brothers, Charles Francis and George Washington Adams, didn’t come to the ceremony. On her wedding day, Mary signed papers to free her enslaved woman Rachel Clark.

The rushed wedding caused a split between the brothers that never healed.

Louisa Adams Predicted Trouble For The Newlyweds

First Lady Louisa Adams worried about the marriage from the start.

She wrote to Charles Francis the day after the wedding: “Madame is cool easy and indifferent as ever.”

The sharp-eyed mother warned Charles not to envy his brother because John “looks already as if he had all the cares in the world upon his shoulders and my heart tells me that here is much to fear.”

Nine months and a week later, Mary had daughter Mary Louisa on December 2, 1828. Pregnancy and motherhood didn’t agree with Mary Hellen, and she grew sick and sad.

Louisa’s gut feeling about the troubled match turned out right.

Alcoholism Gripped The Heartbroken Eldest Son

After John II married Mary Hellen in February 1828, George Washington Adams sank into heavy drinking and sadness. He felt his love failure as deeply as his failure to please his parents.

Though he finished Harvard and started working as a lawyer, his work was nothing special. George drank too much, ran up debts, and made bad choices.

In early April 1829, a child he fathered was born to Eliza Dolph, a maid in the home of Dr. Thomas Welsh, the Adams family’s Boston doctor.

This child born outside marriage added to George’s shame and worsening mental state.

His Father’s Call Filled George With Dread

In spring 1829, John Quincy called George to Washington to help his parents move back to Massachusetts after losing the presidency.

George had just fathered his child with the maid, and his brother Charles Francis wrote that George “shook with fear” at the thought of his parents’ anger.

The idea of facing his let-down father crushed the fragile young man. George got on the steamboat Benjamin Franklin to travel from Boston to Washington.

His mental state got worse with each mile, as he thought about facing the family he had failed.

The Benjamin Franklin Steamboat Became His Final Resting Place

George went missing from the steamship Benjamin Franklin in Long Island Sound on April 30, 1829, while traveling from Boston to Washington. Other travelers last saw him around 2 A.M. , and crew members found his hat and cloak on deck, suggesting he jumped overboard.

George acted confused during the trip, asking the captain to turn back and claiming other passengers plotted against him. He left notes hinting at suicide before boarding.

His body washed up on City Island on June 10. George Washington Adams died at 28, the first victim of the family love triangle.

Three More Deaths Completed The Tragic Family Tale

The curse that began with the White House love triangle claimed more victims in the years that followed.

John Adams II and Mary Hellen had two daughters: Mary Louisa, born December 2, 1828, and Georgiana Frances, born September 10, 1830.

John followed his brother’s self-destructive path, dying of alcoholism complications in 1834 at just 31 years old.

Their daughter Georgiana Frances died at age 9 in 1839, leaving Mary a widow at 31 with one surviving child. Mary Catherine Hellen Adams lived until August 31, 1870, dying in Bethlehem, New Hampshire at sixty-three.

The love triangle that began in the White House ultimately destroyed two of John Quincy Adams’ three sons.

Visiting Adams National Historical Park, Massachusetts

You can explore the Adams family drama at Adams National Historical Park by checking in at 1250 Hancock Street in Quincy. Entrance costs $15 per person (kids under 16 free).

Tours of Peacefield and Stone Library are limited to 10 people and available first-come first-served at the visitor center. The park runs Wednesday through Sunday from June to October.

A trolley connects you between the visitor center, birthplaces, and Peacefield.

This article was created with AI assistance and human editing.

Read more from this brand:

• How a privateering ship became Salem’s first China trader in 1786
• The day 2.3 million gallons of molasses drowned a Boston neighborhood due to corporate negligence
• How a pregnant Cape Cod woman became the “Witch of Wellfleet” after her pirate lover’s shipwreck