A small Missouri town has 550 historic buildings its own Sistine Chapel and real Route 66 soul

Carthage’s Victorian streets and American legends

Carthage sits in the southwest corner of Missouri, where Route 66 crosses the old Jefferson Highway at a spot locals call the Crossroads of America.

More than 550 buildings here sit on the National Register of Historic Places, spread across three historic districts. In October, the maple trees turn, and over 65,000 people show up for the festival.

But this town doesn’t need the fall colors to earn a visit. What’s here year-round goes a lot deeper than foliage.

Burned to the ground, rebuilt in stone

Carthage started in 1842 as the Jasper County seat, named after the ancient city-state. Then in September 1864, pro-Confederate guerrillas torched most of it.

Only the Kendrick House survived. What you see today came from a lead and zinc mining boom in the 1880s and 1890s that pushed so much money into town that wealthy mine owners filled the streets with ornate Victorian homes.

One disaster built the foundation. Another boom built everything on top of it.

The courthouse that stops you mid-stride

The Jasper County Courthouse rises 176 feet above the square, with turrets, towers, and arches in a Romanesque Revival style that architect Max A. Orlopp Jr. finished in 1895.

Missouri residents call it the second most photographed building in the state.

Walk inside and you’ll find a wrought-iron cage elevator that still runs today, more than 130 years after it was installed. Admission is free.

Give yourself time to look up.

The local stone that built Missouri’s landmarks

That courthouse isn’t made of just any rock. It’s Carthage marble, a dense gray limestone hard enough to take a polish, quarried right here in town.

The Missouri State Capitol in Jefferson City went up with the same stone. So did parts of St. Louis.

After an 1880 fire swept through the square, builders wanted something that wouldn’t burn.

The stone beneath Carthage turned out to be exactly what they needed, and it shaped the look of the town for the next century.

Walking past mansions where families still live

The Grand Avenue Historic District holds the grandest homes in town, and they’re not museums. Families still live in them.

Queen Anne, Italianate, and Colonial Revival styles line the street, with fish-scale shingles, wraparound porches, and turrets crowding the rooflines.

Step close enough and you can see the original stained glass and hand-carved woodwork through the windows.

Self-guided walking and driving tours take you past the best examples, and the streets themselves do most of the work.

Fourteen rooms and ten fireplaces on Grand Avenue

At 1146 Grand Avenue, the 1895 Phelps House gives you a close look at how the wealthiest people in southwest Missouri lived.

Colonel William H. Phelps built this 14-room Victorian mansion with marble, stained glass, and ten fireplaces running through it. On the third floor, there’s a small ballroom.

Phelps was one of the most respected figures in the region, and the house reflects that in every detail. Private tours run daily by appointment if you want to get inside.

The chapel with a ceiling painted flat on your back

In 1984, artist Sam Butcher bought land in Carthage and started building a chapel.

Construction ran until it opened in June 1989, and what went up on the walls and ceiling has drawn comparisons to the Sistine Chapel ever since.

There are 84 hand-painted wall murals throughout the building.

The ceiling mural alone covers 1,400 square feet, and Butcher painted it lying on scaffolding 35 feet up, the same way Michelangelo worked five centuries before him.

The self-taught artist who kept painting into his seventies

Butcher grew up poor in Michigan and taught himself to paint.

He created his teardrop-eyed Precious Moments figurines in 1978, and the success of those gave him the means to build the chapel. He kept adding new murals for decades, still working on them into his seventies.

Free guided tours walk you through the murals and the story behind each one. Butcher died at his Carthage home on May 20, 2024, leaving the chapel as his life’s work.

A ghost town rebuilt on a working farm

About three miles outside of town, artist Lowell Davis spent years putting a lost world back together.

Starting in 1987, he moved real buildings from Missouri ghost towns onto his farm and rebuilt his vanished hometown of Red Oak, Missouri. The village has a general store, schoolhouse, jail, diner, and church.

Real people live in some of the homes. Davis himself lived in a house that once belonged to outlaw Belle Starr.

You can walk through it today.

Clark Gable slept here, and the sign still says so

The Boots Court Motel opened in 1939 right at the Crossroads of America, built by Arthur Boots in the sleek Streamline Moderne style. The original signs still advertise the radios in every room.

Clark Gable stayed in rooms 6 and 10 in 1942 and 1947. Gene Autry and Mickey Mantle were guests too.

The motel later fell into disrepair and came within reach of the wrecking ball before a full restoration brought it back. By 2023, it was running again.

Double features under the stars since 1949

On Sept. 22, 1949, the 66 Drive-In Theatre opened on a nine-acre lot about three miles west of town. The 66-foot-tall screen house is mostly original.

The drive-in ran until 1985, sat dark for over a decade, then reopened in April 1998. From April through October, it runs weekend double features.

Sound comes through your car’s FM radio, same as drive-ins used to do it. The screen lights up at dark and the lot fills up fast on warm weekends.

The wildlife host who grew up on these streets

Marlin Perkins was born in Carthage on March 28, 1905, and went on to host Mutual of Omaha’s Wild Kingdom from 1963 to 1985. The show ran in 40 countries and pulled 35 million viewers.

You’ll find his statue in Central Park, a bronze figure crouched with binoculars, captured mid-scan exactly as he looked on TV.

The base carries a line from Shakespeare: “Nature might stand up to him and say, this was a man.” Worth a stop.

Visit Carthage, Missouri

You can start your visit at the Experience Carthage visitor center at 326 Grant St., open Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. to 5 p.m., where staff can hand you walking tour maps and point you toward the day’s best stops.

The Maple Leaf Festival runs each October and draws more than 65,000 people, so book ahead if that’s your window. Most of the town’s highlights, from the courthouse to the drive-in, cost little to nothing to see.

This article was created with AI assistance and human editing.

Read more from this brand:

• The last enslaved person owned by a U.S. president walked free on March 29, 1859
• Death by cottonwood: old Missouri’s underwater forest of terror
• Prison time for Missouri politician that used COVID-19 relief funds for personal expenses