17,000 Retirees Leave NYC as Cost of Living Pushes Seniors Out

And They’re All Going to the Same Places

In 2023, nearly 24,000 people aged 60 and over packed up and left New York City. Only about 6,800 moved in.

That net loss of 17,000 retirees was three times larger than any other American city. Los Angeles, San Diego, Washington D.C. , and Denver also watched seniors leave in big numbers.

But the real story isn’t just who’s leaving. It’s where they’re going, and why the math finally stopped making sense.

California Loses Four Cities

Los Angeles came in second for retiree losses with a net outflow of 3,187. San Diego followed at 2,604.

Oakland lost 2,016 retirees, and San Jose lost 1,668. That put four California cities in the top 10 for retiree exodus.

At the state level, California lost more retirees than any other state, with a net 56,858 people aged 60 and over leaving in 2023. The pattern was clear.

Seniors were done with the Golden State’s price tag.

The Capital and Denver Empty Out

Washington D. C. lost 2,434 retirees, with 5,144 moving out and only 2,710 moving in. Denver wasn’t far behind, losing 2,286 seniors as 4,087 left and just 1,801 arrived.

Arlington, Virginia, lost 1,703 retirees. Chicago lost 1,699.

Anchorage, Alaska, rounded out the top 10 with a loss of 1,413. These cities span different regions and climates, but they share one thing: high costs.

You Need a Million Dollars

A majority of the top 10 cities that retirees are leaving are in states where you typically need over $1 million in savings to retire comfortably.

WalletHub ranked New York City as the priciest city to retire in. In New York state, you can expect to need around $1.3 million in savings to retire, while in California you’ll need about $1. 6 million.

For seniors on fixed incomes, those numbers don’t add up.

Florida Wins by a Landslide

Florida gained the most retirees of any state, with a net migration of 44,504 seniors. That was more than double second-place North Carolina, which gained 20,369.

Nearly 143,400 retirees moved into Florida in 2023, while about 98,900 moved out.

The Sunshine State has long been a retirement destination, but the gap between Florida and everywhere else is getting wider.

No State Tax on Retirement

Florida has no state income tax. That means any earnings, whether from wages, pensions, or retirement accounts, are tax-free at the state level. Social Security benefits go untaxed.

If you’re pulling $50,000 a year from your retirement accounts, you’re not handing a chunk of that over to the state. For retirees watching every dollar, that tax break can mean thousands saved each year.

Arizona and Nevada Draw Crowds

Mesa, Arizona, gained the most retirees of any city in the study, with a net gain of 2,044. In Nevada, North Las Vegas gained 1,420 retirees.

Paradise gained 1,416. Spring Valley added 1,312, and Henderson added 1,194.

Scottsdale, Arizona, also made the top 10 with a gain of 904. The Southwest offers warm weather, lower costs, and in Nevada’s case, no state income tax either.

North Carolina Surprises Everyone

North Carolina ranked second among states for retiree gains, with a net of 20,369 seniors moving in. Arizona was close behind at 20,203.

Durham cracked the top 10 for cities gaining retirees, adding a net 1,117 seniors.

The state offers milder winters than the Northeast, lower costs than California, and a growing reputation as a landing spot for people leaving expensive metros.

Ann Arbor Shrinks the Fastest

While New York City had the largest raw numbers, Ann Arbor, Michigan, lost retirees at the fastest rate relative to its population size. The college town saw 889 more seniors leave than arrive.

At the state level, Michigan lost 4,161 retirees overall. Cold winters and rising costs pushed seniors toward warmer, cheaper alternatives.

The brain drain isn’t just about young people anymore.

The Math Finally Broke

Retirees may choose to move for various reasons, such as being closer to family, enjoying better weather, or taking advantage of more favorable tax laws, but a high cost of living can also be a major factor.

Rent, groceries, transportation, and healthcare are all more expensive in urban areas.

Retirees who sell homes in major metros can often buy comparable properties in smaller towns and still pocket the difference.

Cities Face a New Problem

Wider trends in migration among this demographic have potential implications for the local tax base, housing market, and business environment. When retirees leave, they take their spending with them.

Restaurants, healthcare providers, and service businesses that rely on senior customers feel the pinch.

Meanwhile, destination states see their populations age rapidly, creating new demands for healthcare and infrastructure.

The Great Retiree Reshuffle

Nearly one million people aged 60 and over in the U. S. crossed state lines to make a new home in 2023. That’s a lot of moving trucks heading in the same direction.

The seniors leaving New York and California aren’t scattered across the map. They’re landing in Florida, Arizona, Nevada, and the Carolinas.

For cities watching their retirees leave, the question isn’t whether to compete. It’s whether they even can.

This article was created with AI assistance and human editing.

Read more from this brand:

• Alabama is stealing Florida’s retirees and nobody saw it coming
• This Montana ranch bred super horses that conquered the Wild West
• These 12 least-visited US national parks are hidden gems worth exploring