The NYC suburb built on 21,000 tons of chemical waste and pushed Congress to create the Superfund law

The Love Canal Disaster

William T. Love started digging a canal in 1894 near Niagara Falls to create hydroelectric power. He abandoned the project after digging only a mile when his money ran out and alternating current technology made his plan obsolete.

The empty trench became a dump for Niagara Falls in the 1920s. Hooker Chemical bought the site in 1942 and filled it with industrial waste until 1953. During this time, workers dumped about 21,000 tons of toxic chemicals into the canal. These included twelve substances known to cause cancer, like benzene, dioxin, and chloroform.

Hooker Chemical’s $1 Sale to the School Board

Hooker Chemical covered the 16-acre waste site with clay and sold it to the Niagara Falls School Board for $1 in 1953. The deed warned about the buried chemicals and freed Hooker from future responsibility.

School officials ignored these clear warnings. They needed land for new schools as Niagara Falls grew after World War II. Hooker tried to limit the land use to parks only. The board refused this restriction, determined to build a school on the property despite the risks.

Residential Development and the 99th Street School

The school board built the 99th Street School directly on the former canal in 1954-1955. Children played daily on grounds covering toxic waste. The city approved homes around the canal area.

By 1978, about 800 houses and 240 apartments surrounded the site. Construction workers damaged the clay cap and canal walls while installing sewers and water pipes. This broke the barrier holding in the chemicals and created paths for poisons to spread through the neighborhood.

First Signs of Chemical Leakage

Heavy rain and snow in 1976-1977 pushed groundwater up, forcing chemicals to the surface. Water carried dissolved chemicals through the soil into homes. Families found black sludge and noticed strange smells in their basements and yards.

Many discovered oily substances bubbling up through their basement floors. In 1976, county health officials began investigating reports of contamination. By 1977, environmental officials urged New York State to take legal action against Hooker Chemical.

The Health Crisis Emerges

Tests in early 1978 found over 80 different chemicals in water samples from homes near the canal. This confirmed what residents had feared. Michael Brown, a local reporter, went door-to-door and found alarming rates of birth defects, miscarriages, and illnesses.

His newspaper articles brought attention to the growing crisis. Families reported many health problems: epilepsy, asthma, migraines, skin rashes, and cancer. Dr. Beverly Paigen’s research confirmed that women living near the canal had unusually high rates of miscarriages and children with birth defects.

Lois Gibbs and the Love Canal Homeowners Association

Lois Gibbs, whose son became sick while attending the 99th Street School, stepped up as a community leader in 1978. When school officials refused to transfer her son to another school, she began organizing neighbors.

She formed the Love Canal Homeowners Association in August 1978. The group gathered health data, staged protests, and demanded government help. Their grassroots work turned worried neighbors into determined activists fighting for their families’ safety against government inaction.

New York State’s Emergency Declaration

New York’s Health Commissioner Robert Whalen declared a health emergency at Love Canal on August 2, 1978. This was the first time officials admitted how serious the situation had become. He ordered pregnant women and children under two years old to leave immediately.

Officials closed the 99th Street School permanently. The state then ordered 239 families from homes closest to the canal to relocate. New York spent nearly $7 million buying these contaminated houses.

Federal Emergency Declaration by President Carter

President Jimmy Carter declared the first-ever federal emergency for a man-made disaster on August 7, 1978. No president had ever taken such action for a non-natural disaster.

Federal money poured in to help with cleanup and moving residents. This national response showed how serious the Love Canal crisis had become. Workers dug trenches to collect leaking chemicals and sealed home sump pumps to prevent toxic vapors from entering houses.

These efforts aimed to stop poisons from spreading further.

The Fight for Further Evacuations

Hundreds of families still lived in contaminated areas outside the first evacuation zone. Their homes tested positive for chemicals, but they received no help. Desperate residents stepped up protests.

In May 1980, they even held two EPA officials for six hours after tests showed genetic damage in 11 residents. President Carter responded with a second emergency declaration on May 21, 1980.

This expanded the evacuation zone by 350 acres, allowing about 700 more families to relocate with government assistance.

Birth of the Superfund Law

Love Canal directly led to the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act, known as Superfund. This law created a system for cleaning up toxic waste sites across America.

Congress passed the Superfund law on December 11, 1980, and President Carter signed it before leaving office. The law created a $1.6 billion fund paid for by taxes on chemical and oil companies.

Love Canal became the first site on the National Priorities List, marking the beginning of a nationwide cleanup effort.

The Cleanup and Litigation

The EPA sued Occidental Chemical (which had bought Hooker) in 1988 for cleanup costs. This legal fight established that companies must pay for past pollution, even if their actions were legal when they occurred.

Occidental paid $129 million in 1995 to settle the case. This was one of the largest environmental payments ever made. The cleanup included a system to collect contaminated water, a new cap over the site, and a plant to treat the toxic liquid.

Workers also demolished the most contaminated homes.

Visiting The Former Love Canal Neighborhood in Niagara Falls, New York

The former Love Canal neighborhood exists in the southeast corner of Niagara Falls, New York. The actual canal area remains fenced off with no public access permitted due to ongoing contamination.

You can view the restricted area from public streets along the perimeter. A historical marker on 99th Street marks where the school once stood. The rehabilitated homes in Black Creek Village surround the containment area, now occupied by new residents.

For more context, visit the Love Canal Collections at the University at Buffalo Archives, which preserves documents and photographs from this environmental disaster. The Niagara Falls Public Library also maintains historical records about Love Canal.

The original contamination zone lies approximately 5 miles from Niagara Falls State Park, making it possible to combine a visit with the region’s other historical and natural attractions.

Read More on WhenInYourState.com:

• The Historic House Where Washington Watched New York Burn on September 21, 1776
• The Revolutionary War ambush that turned the Iroquois Confederacy against itself in upstate New York
• How 705 Titanic passengers ended up alive in New York thanks to an unexpected rescue ship