“Put on petticoats”: When Tecumseh saved prisoners after Dudley’s defeat

Kentucky’s Fatal March Into British-Indian Ambush

Fort Meigs in Ohio shows what happens when courage becomes foolishness.

On May 5, 1813, Colonel William Dudley led 866 Kentucky militiamen across the Maumee River to destroy British cannons.

They completed their mission but ignored orders to return. Instead, they chased retreating warriors into the woods where Tecumseh’s men surrounded them.

Only 150 escaped. Dudley died in the first minutes, and surviving prisoners faced execution until Tecumseh himself stopped the slaughter.

The fort’s blockhouse exhibits tell the complete story of how bravery turned deadly.

Kentucky Reinforcements Rushed to Save Fort Meigs

On May 4, 1813, General Green Clay arrived at the Maumee River with 1,200 Kentucky militiamen while British forces besieged Fort Meigs.

General William Henry Harrison ordered Clay to split his forces: 800 men should cross to the north bank, disable the British cannons, and return to the fort right away.

The other 400 needed to fight their way into the fort. Clay picked Colonel William Dudley of the 13th Kentucky Militia Regiment to lead the main attack force.

The Surprise Attack Worked Perfectly… At First

Dudley’s 800 Kentuckians launched their surprise attack on the British artillery positions at 9 AM on May 5. The Americans quickly beat the British gunners and took over the cannons.

They tried to disable the guns but used ramrods instead of proper iron spikes, which only stopped the cannons temporarily.

The British troops backed away toward the woods as planned, with the Americans getting what they came for.

Revenge-Hungry Soldiers Ignored Their Orders

The Kentucky militiamen chased after the retreating British and Native Americans, completely ignoring Harrison’s direct orders to return to Fort Meigs.

Colonel Dudley tried to stop his men but the untrained volunteers paid no attention.

The Kentuckians wanted payback for their fellow statesmen killed at the River Raisin Massacre months earlier.

Tecumseh’s warriors started leading the Americans deeper into the woods, away from the safety of the fort.

The Forest Turned Into a Deadly Maze

Tecumseh’s warriors pulled the scattered Kentuckians deeper into the forest. The Americans got more and more lost as they followed their enemies through unfamiliar land.

British regular troops and Canadian militia regrouped and prepared to attack again. The Kentuckians soon found themselves surrounded in a carefully planned trap with no way out.

Colonel Dudley Met a Brutal End

The British and Native Americans attacked from all sides. Colonel Dudley got shot in the leg and body during the first minutes of fighting.

Native American warriors scalped Dudley while he was still alive, then cut up his body. With their leader dead and officers wounded, the Kentucky militiamen lost all control and order.

Hundreds Died in the Chaotic Forest Battle

Kentucky militiamen fought for their lives in confused, close fighting throughout the forest. From Dudley’s original 866 officers and men, about 220 died in the fighting.

Another 350 survivors got captured after being overwhelmed by too many enemies. Only 150 Kentuckians managed to escape back to Fort Meigs.

The Long Walk to Fort Miami

The British and Native Americans marched 350 captured Kentucky militiamen downriver to the ruins of Fort Miami.

The tired and wounded prisoners walked several miles under guard.

British Colonel Henry Procter set up his headquarters at the ruined fort while planning the next part of his siege. Guards kept the prisoners in the open courtyard of the abandoned fort, with no protection.

The Slaughter Pen Turned Horrific

Native American warriors began randomly shooting into the group of helpless prisoners. Warriors started tomahawking captives and taking their belongings and clothes.

They killed at least 30 prisoners in what people later called the “slaughter pen.” Colonel Procter and other British officers watched from a distance but did nothing to stop it.

Tecumseh Showed More Honor Than the British

Tecumseh arrived at Fort Miami and immediately saw Native Americans killing the helpless prisoners. The Shawnee chief pulled out his tomahawk and physically stood between the prisoners and their attackers.

Tecumseh ordered his warriors to stop the killing and threatened anyone who continued. The massacre stopped as soon as Tecumseh stepped in, saving the lives of the remaining prisoners.

A Chief Shamed the British Commander

Tecumseh angrily confronted Colonel Procter for failing to protect the prisoners under his watch. When Procter claimed he couldn’t control the Native Americans, Tecumseh called him “unfit to command.”

The Shawnee chief told Procter to “go and put on petticoats” for his cowardice. Tecumseh reportedly said “I conquer to save, you to kill” to show the difference.

The Costly Lesson of Dudley’s Defeat

The disaster cost Harrison nearly 650 casualties out of 800 men, but British artillery had been stopped for a while.

General Harrison later criticized Kentucky militia’s “too much eagerness,” noting their bravery “sometimes has the same result as cowardice.”

“Dudley’s Massacre” joined “Remember the Raisin” as a battle cry that fired up future Kentucky volunteers.

The British siege fell apart days later when Native American allies lost interest and Canadian militia wanted to go home.

Visiting Fort Meigs, Ohio

Fort Meigs at 29100 West River Road in Perrysburg tells the story of Dudley’s Massacre through its Legacy of Freedom museum and reconstructed ten-acre fort.

Admission costs $12 for adults, $10 for seniors, and $7 for students, with guided tours at 11am and 3pm included.

The museum displays War of 1812 artifacts like soldiers’ letters and weapons year-round, while the fort with seven blockhouses and five artillery batteries opens April through October.

This article was created with AI assistance and human editing.

Read more from this brand:

• The Story of Omar Bradley, “the G.I.’s General” and World War II Legend
• The forgotten displacement of Oglala Lakota families for a WWII bombing range in South Dakota
• How a Navy SEAL from Long Island ended up having a museum named after him