Connect with us

Ohio

The one American city where chili has cinnamon, pizza has sausage made with oats, and no one apologizes

Published

 

on

Aerial view of Downtown Cincinnati and the bridges crossing the Ohio River from Kentucky to Ohio from Devou Park, which has a commanding view of downtown Covington, Kentucky and Cincinnati, Ohio.

Cincinnati’s food scene didn’t happen by accident

Cincinnati’s food identity runs deep, back to the 1800s when German, Greek, and Macedonian immigrants each planted roots in this Ohio river city and cooked what they knew. What came out of those kitchens didn’t disappear.

It became the city’s signature. Today, chili parlors outnumber Starbucks, a sausage made with oats shows up on pizza, and a 150-year-old ice cream company still packs its pints by hand. You came to eat.

You picked the right city.

CINCINNATI, USA - SEPTEMBER 5, 2024 - Pig sculptures outdoor 5 left from The Big Pig Gig public art exhibits on display in in the summers of 2000 artists decorated hundreds of pig statues.

When Cincinnati was the hog capital of America

In the 1840s and 1850s, Cincinnati was the country’s top pork-processing center. Thousands of hogs moved through city streets on their way to dozens of packing houses.

German immigrants, who made up roughly 40 percent of the city’s population by the 1850s, brought a deep preference for pork with them, and the industry grew to match it.

Butchery, sausage-making, and soap production all grew out of that meat trade. The nickname “Porkopolis” stuck, and so did the food culture it created.

You still see the flying pig on public art, race finisher medals, and murals all over town.

Cincinnati chili, spiced meat sauce, white onion, grated cheddar cheese on top of spaghetti on plate on rustic wood table with forks, american cuisine, close-up, not AI generated

Cincinnati chili will completely rewrite your expectations

Forget Texas. Cincinnati chili is a Mediterranean-spiced meat sauce seasoned with cinnamon, allspice, cloves, and warm spices you’d more likely find in a Greek or Middle Eastern kitchen.

Macedonian immigrant Tom Kiradjieff created it at his Empress restaurant in the 1920s. You don’t eat it from a bowl.

It comes over spaghetti or spooned onto a hot dog.

When you order, you order by “ways”: a three-way gets you spaghetti, chili, and a mound of shredded cheddar. A four-way adds onions or beans.

A five-way has everything.

CINCINNATI, OHIO-DECEMBER 30, 2017: Skyline Chili is a chain of restaurants founded in 1949 and headquartered in Cincinnati. They features chili. There are over 150 restuarnats in the midwest.

The chili parlors worth lining up for

Dixie Chili has been open since 1929. Camp Washington Chili, open since 1940, won a James Beard America’s Classics Award in 2000.

Skyline Chili was founded in 1949 by Greek immigrant Nicholas Lambrinides and now runs over 160 locations.

Gold Star Chili started in 1965 when four brothers from Jordan noticed chili outsold their burgers and pivoted hard. About 250 chili parlors operate across the Cincinnati region.

That’s not a food trend. That’s a food infrastructure, and every neighborhood has its loyalists.

Goetta: meat, breakfast, sausage, pork, cincinnati, tasty, german-american, homemade, savory, fried, beef, delicious, spices, oats, traditional, fresh, food, meal, photo, cook, image

Goetta: a sausage that barely exists outside this city

Goetta is pork, beef, steel-cut oats, and spices, sliced thick and fried until the outside goes crispy. German immigrants from northwestern Germany brought the recipe in the mid-1800s.

The name traces back to the Low German word “Gotte,” meaning groats or coarse grains.

Glier’s Goetta, established in 1946, produces over one million pounds a year, and 99 percent of it stays in the Cincinnati area.

You’ll find it at breakfast spots, on pizza, tucked into sliders, and piled into egg sandwiches. Eckerlin Meats at Findlay Market has been making it from a family recipe for generations.

CINCINNATI, OHIO - JUNE 18, 2017: Findlay Market is a trendy farmer's marketplace in the historic Over the Rhine district in Cincinnati, Ohio. It attracts hundreds of visitors daily.

Findlay Market has been open since before the Civil War

Findlay Market opened in 1852 in the Over-the-Rhine neighborhood and has run continuously ever since. It’s the last of the nine public markets that once served Cincinnati.

The land came from the estate of General James Findlay, an early city settler, and the building was among the first in the country to use iron-frame construction.

The National Register of Historic Places has it on the list.

Today, dozens of indoor vendors sell meat, produce, cheese, baked goods, and prepared food, and the market pulls in over one million visitors a year.

Breakfast with goetta and fried egg on plate (Cincinnati Breakfast Classic)

What to eat the moment you walk through the door

Go straight to Eckerlin Meats for their goetta, egg, and cheese breakfast sandwich, made fresh every morning from a recipe that’s been in the family for generations.

Taste of Belgium, which started at Findlay Market in 2007, makes Liege-style waffles with caramelized pearl sugar that gets chewy and slightly crunchy at the edges.

Avril-Bleh Meat Market, founded in 1894 and now in its fifth generation, carries over 35 types of sausage.

Come on a Saturday between March and December and the farmers market sets up outside with local produce, baked goods, and street performers in the mix.

It's their signature flavor. Tasty.

Graeter’s ice cream is made 2.5 gallons at a time on purpose

Louis Charles Graeter started selling ice cream on Cincinnati streets in 1870.

The company still uses the French Pot process, spinning small 2.5-gallon batches in a way that makes the ice cream too dense for a machine to pack. Every pint gets hand-packed.

The chocolate chunks aren’t chips, they’re formed by pouring melted chocolate directly into the spinning pot, which breaks into irregular pieces of all different sizes.

Graeter’s is the only commercial ice cream maker in the world still using this method. The best-selling flavor, Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip, uses Oregon black raspberries.

CINCINNATI, OHIO - JUNE 18, 2017: Findlay Market is a trendy farmer's marketplace in the historic Over the Rhine district in Cincinnati, OH.

Over-the-Rhine: the neighborhood that kept its bones

German immigrants settled Over-the-Rhine in the mid-1800s and named it for the canal they compared to Germany’s Rhine River.

The neighborhood holds one of the largest collections of well-preserved Italianate architecture anywhere in the country, and in the past 15 years it’s become one of Cincinnati’s top dining districts.

The blocks are compact and walkable, so you can cover a lot of ground on foot. Sotto, a basement-level Italian restaurant, makes handmade pasta and wood-fired bread.

The Eagle built its reputation on fried chicken finished with hot honey.

Crowds enjoy regional cuisine on Fifth Street at Taste of Cincinnati 2014.

The food festivals that bring out half a million people

Taste of Cincinnati runs every Memorial Day weekend on Fifth Street downtown and holds the title of the nation’s longest-running culinary arts festival.

Dozens of local restaurants, food trucks, and Findlay Market vendors set up across three days, and past award-winning dishes have included braised short rib over gnocchi and black raspberry chip cheesecake.

Glier’s Goettafest crosses the river to Newport, Kentucky for two weekends every summer, celebrating goetta in every form the city’s cooks can think up.

Over half a million people show up for Taste of Cincinnati alone.

CINCINNATI, OHIO - JUNE 18, 2017: Findlay Market is a trendy farmer's marketplace in the historic Over the Rhine district in Cincinnati, OH.

Cincinnati chefs are on the national radar right now

Three Cincinnati restaurants landed 2026 James Beard Award finalist spots.

Chef Sarah Dworak of Sudova, known for elevated Eastern European dishes like pierogi and borscht, is a finalist for Best Chef: Great Lakes.

Chef Jeffrey Harris of Nolia Kitchen, which serves New Orleans-inspired Southern cuisine, is a finalist in the same category.

The city’s culinary identity pulls from German, Greek, Southern, and global traditions, all layered on top of each other, and the chefs working here right now are pushing that further than it’s ever gone.

Cincinnati, Ohio, July 30, 2022: One of many outdoor cafes in Over The Rhine area in Cincinnati, OH, making it a popular destination for locals and visitors

Few cities put history on a plate the way Cincinnati does

Cincinnati’s signature dishes, from chili to goetta to hand-packed ice cream, didn’t come from marketing. They came from immigrant kitchens trying to feed families with what they knew.

Almost none of it traveled far. The chili parlors, Findlay Market, and the Over-the-Rhine dining district all sit within a few miles of each other.

The whole food circuit is walkable, affordable, and rooted in the community that built it. If you’re the kind of person who eats to understand a place, Cincinnati will give you a lot to work with.

Cincinnati, Ohio, USA - Dec. 6, 2024: Historic Findlay Market in Cincinnati's colorful Over the Rhine neighborhood is Ohio's oldest continuously operating public market and a popular destination.

Start your Cincinnati food tour at Findlay Market

You can build a solid two-day food itinerary without a car.

Start at Findlay Market for breakfast, pick up a goetta sandwich from Eckerlin Meats, then walk through Over-the-Rhine for lunch or dinner at Sotto or The Eagle.

A chili parlor stop is non-negotiable: Camp Washington for the James Beard pedigree, Skyline for the classic chain experience, or a neighborhood spot for the local version.

Track down a Graeter’s location for Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip. If your timing lines up with Memorial Day weekend or a summer Saturday, even better.

Findlay Market is located at 1801 Race St., Cincinnati, Ohio 45202.

Hours vary by vendor, but the market generally runs Tuesday through Sunday, with extended Saturday hours for the outdoor farmers market. Admission is free.

This article was created with AI assistance and human editing.

Read more from this brand:

John Ghost is a professional writer and SEO director. He graduated from Arizona State University with a BA in English (Writing, Rhetorics, and Literacies). As he prepares for graduate school to become an English professor, he writes weird fiction, plays his guitars, and enjoys spending time with his wife and daughters. He lives in the Valley of the Sun. Learn more about John on Muck Rack.

Trending Posts