Connect with us

Oklahoma

The 25-day mail promise that built Wells Fargo across 2,800 miles

Published

 

on

John Butterfield’s Stagecoach Empire Across the American Frontier

The Butterfield Overland trail markers in Oklahoma tell the story of America’s most ambitious stagecoach dream.

John Butterfield grew up dirt poor on a New York farm but became a stage driver by nineteen. He saved every penny, bought his own business, and soon controlled stage lines across the state.

In 1850, he convinced rivals Henry Wells and William Fargo to merge into American Express. Seven years later, he carried mail from St. Louis to San Francisco in just 25 days.

This is the story of how one farm boy built an empire that became Wells Fargo and American Express.

From Stagecoach Driver to Business Tycoon

John Butterfield started with almost nothing.

Born in 1801 on a small farm in New York, he got little schooling but grew up when new ways to travel were taking off. He got a job driving stages in Albany at age 19.

While taking people between taverns and boats, Butterfield saved every penny, setting up his future success.

His Shrewd Business Skills Built an Empire

After marrying Malinda Baker in 1822, Butterfield bought his own livery business. His knack for smart moves helped him take over most stage lines west of New York.

He grew beyond stagecoaches into steamboats on Lake Ontario, street railroads, plank roads, and the Black River Railroad.

By 1849, he started Butterfield, Wasson & Company express service.

Three Rivals Join Forces to Create American Express

Henry Wells from Auburn and William Fargo from Pompey started their own businesses using Butterfield’s travel network.

Instead of fighting them, Butterfield saw a better path. He talked Wells and Fargo into joining forces instead of competing.

In 1850, they merged to create the American Express Company. The new business had two main parts run by the partners, making it stronger than any could be alone.

The Government Contract Nobody Thought Possible

In April 1857, the government asked for bids on “Overland Mail Service to California,” worth $600,000 yearly.

Nine companies bid, all suggesting northern routes above Albuquerque. Butterfield’s company won this contract, the biggest mail deal ever from the US government.

The Southern Postmaster General added a twist, making the route go through Arkansas to El Paso, adding 600 more miles to the trip.

He Built 139 Stations Without Ever Seeing the West

Butterfield spent over $1 million building the world’s longest stagecoach line.

He set up 139 relay stations across 2,800 miles, hired 800 people, bought 250 coaches and 1,800 animals.

His crews built roads, bridges, dug wells, and cleared mountain passes in just one year.

Most amazing, Butterfield created this huge system without ever going west of Buffalo himself, using only reports and maps.

The Yellow-Coated Boss Carried the First Mail Himself

When the first run started on September 16, 1858, Butterfield showed up in a yellow linen coat and flat-brimmed hat to carry the first mail himself.

He left St.Louis with two mail bags and reporter Waterman Ormsby, who planned to write about the whole trip.

After 12 hours, Butterfield handed things to his son at Tipton, Missouri. The father only rode as far as Fort Smith, but Ormsby stuck with it for the tough 2,812-mile journey.

Mail Delivery Beats the Clock by Over a Day

The first mail reached San Francisco in just 23 days and 23. 5 hours, beating the 25-day goal. The service soon ran twice weekly, carrying up to 12,000 letters.

Travelers paid $200 one-way, about $3,000 today, to bounce across the country in a crowded coach with riders and passengers alike.

Butterfield made sure everyone knew his motto: “Remember boys, nothing on God’s earth must stop the mail.”

Money Problems Hit When Congress Drops the Ball

Trouble started in 1859 when Congress failed to pass the Post Office budget. Without this money, the government couldn’t pay the Overland Mail Company.

Butterfield had to borrow $162,000 from Wells Fargo just to keep the coaches running. As the company fell deeper in debt to Wells Fargo, workers lost heart and the business began to struggle.

Wells Fargo Takes Control in a Boardroom Showdown

Things came to a head on March 17, 1860, when Wells Fargo asked for all company assets to cover the unpaid debt.

Butterfield got so angry he walked out of the meeting. Three days later, they reached a deal, but Butterfield lost his job as president.

William Dinsmore from Adams Express took over, and Wells Fargo gained control of the company Butterfield had built from scratch.

The Civil War Forces a Complete Route Change

The last Butterfield stage finished the southern “Ox-bow Route” on March 21, 1861.

As the Civil War started, the government closed the southern route and moved service to a central route.

Moving all the stock and coaches north took huge effort, and workers spent three months rebuilding stations along the new northern path.

Wells Fargo took the western portion while Ben Holladay ran the eastern part.

The Stress of Losing His Dream Broke His Health

The stress of building the venture, dealing with the route change, and losing his contract took a heavy toll on Butterfield.

At age 59, he suffered a physical breakdown and retired to Utica, New York.

His health continued to decline, and he later had a paralyzing stroke. Butterfield died on November 14, 1869, just days before his 68th birthday.

Though he didn’t live to see it, the companies he founded evolved into modern American Express and Wells Fargo, and his transportation network became the template that railroads later followed to connect America coast to coast.

Visiting Butterfield Overland, Oklahoma

You can explore John Butterfield’s stagecoach empire legacy at 12 granite and bronze markers across southeastern Oklahoma.

Visit Walker’s Station marker at Skullyville Cemetery on Spring Road near Spiro in LeFlore County. Boggy Depot State Park preserves a Butterfield station site with camping and interpretive trails.

All historical markers and trail sites are free to visit. The Oklahoma Historical Society and Choctaw/Chickasaw Nations manage the markers.

You can see original trail swales and wagon ruts at select locations.

This article was created with AI assistance and human editing.

Read more from this brand:

John Ghost is a professional writer and SEO director. He graduated from Arizona State University with a BA in English (Writing, Rhetorics, and Literacies). As he prepares for graduate school to become an English professor, he writes weird fiction, plays his guitars, and enjoys spending time with his wife and daughters. He lives in the Valley of the Sun. Learn more about John on Muck Rack.

Trending Posts