How one stubborn admiral proved the US Navy wrong about education

Stephen Luce’s Naval War College in Newport’s Poorhouse

In 1884, a run-down poorhouse in Newport, Rhode Island got a strange new life.

Rear Admiral Stephen B. Luce stood in the empty building and spoke words that would change naval history: “Poor little poorhouse, I christen thee United States Naval War College.”

Most Navy men back then thought book learning was useless. But Luce saw that modern steel ships needed modern thinking. On October 6, Secretary Chandler made it official with General Order 325.

Soon after, this first-of-its-kind school began turning out officers who could think, not just fight. The Naval War College Museum now stands where America’s naval brain trust was born.

A Navy Admiral Spotted a Huge Problem in Officer Training

In the 1880s, Rear Admiral Stephen B. Luce noticed something was missing in Navy training.

Officers knew how to sail ships and fire cannons but lacked knowledge about naval strategy and tactics.

The Navy taught hands-on skills but not the deeper parts of warfare.

Luce pushed for a school where officers could study strategy, international law, and military history. Many in the Navy didn’t agree with him because they valued on-ship experience more than classroom learning.

The Navy Finally Got Its First War College in 1884

On October 6, 1884, Navy Secretary William E. Chandler signed the order that created the Naval War College, the first school of its kind anywhere.

The timing couldn’t have been better as the Navy moved from wooden sailing ships to modern steel vessels. Luce had pushed for this for years.

The college aimed to teach officers about modern naval warfare through study rather than just technical training.

From Poorhouse to Powerhouse of Naval Thinking

Luce picked an odd location for his new college: an old, empty poorhouse on Coasters Harbor Island in Newport, Rhode Island. The building once housed the city’s poor people.

During the opening ceremony, Luce told the empty building: “Poor little poorhouse, I christen thee United States Naval War College.”

The simple building didn’t look like much, but it became the first home for advanced naval education in America.

Many Officers Thought Book Learning Was Useless

Many naval officers fought against Luce’s idea. They believed the only way to learn naval warfare was through time at sea.

Some made fun of the idea of officers sitting in classrooms instead of commanding ships. Most thought book learning couldn’t prepare anyone for real combat.

Luce kept fighting for the college anyway, believing that education would make the Navy stronger.

A One-Eyed Lieutenant Volunteered to Help the New College

Lieutenant William McCarty Little joined the college in 1884 as an unpaid helper. He lost sight in one eye in 1876, which cut his active naval career short.

Little still wanted to serve the Navy despite his bad eye.

He brought useful ideas from his travels in Europe, where he had studied how Germans trained their officers. His eye injury led him to Newport where his work would change naval education forever.

War Games Came to Newport in 1886

Little gave six important talks in 1886-1887 that brought war games to the Naval War College. He took ideas from German war games and changed them to fit naval situations.

His games let officers practice making decisions without the risks of real battle. This was brand new for American naval training.

Little created the first way for naval officers to test their ideas safely before lives were at stake.

The Secret Sauce Was Adding a Real Opponent

Little made his war games special by adding what he called “a live, strong enemy in the next room waiting to take advantage of any of our mistakes.”

Unlike basic drills, his games had thinking opponents who changed their plans. This forced officers to deal with surprise and changing conditions.

Players had to make choices under pressure, just like in real fights. Little’s method showed officers that battle plans often fall apart when facing a real enemy.

Tabletop Oceans Let Officers Test Battle Plans

Little created hands-on games using models on flat surfaces that looked like oceans and coastlines. Officers moved ship models around these tabletop seas to see operations and test plans.

The physical games helped players understand how forces moved in space. Players could see what happened after they made decisions.

These touchable simulations helped connect theory with practice and gave officers a concrete way to try tactics safely.

War Games Became the Heart of Naval Education

Little’s war games soon became the main part of Naval War College teaching. What started as a new teaching method became the foundation of officer education.

The college built special rooms for running more complex games. Students spent hundreds of hours playing various scenarios and studying the results.

The approach worked so well that other military schools started using similar methods.

World War II Leaders Credited War Games for Victory

Officers who played Little’s war games at Newport later commanded fleets during World War II.

Fleet Admiral Chester Nimitz, who led Pacific operations, later said that Naval War College gaming had prepared officers so well that “nothing that happened during the war was a surprise except the kamikaze tactics.”

The games had practiced many of the actual challenges commanders faced in the Pacific theater against Japanese forces.

Congress Gave Little a Special Promotion for His Work

Congress recognized Little’s enormous contributions in 1903 by passing a special act promoting him to captain. They also permanently assigned him to the Naval War College faculty, an unprecedented honor.

Today, the college’s massive 110,000 square foot wargaming center bears Little’s name, continuing his legacy.

Though he began as an unpaid volunteer, Little transformed naval education through his innovative approach. His methods continue to influence military training worldwide.

The modern center hosts sophisticated computer simulations that evolved from Little’s tabletop games over a century ago.

Visiting Naval War College Museum, Rhode Island

The Naval War College Museum at 686 Cushing Road in Newport shows how Stephen B. Luce transformed naval education in a former poorhouse.

You need security clearance to visit the base, so U.S. citizens must submit visitor forms 7 days ahead and non-citizens need 14 days.

The museum is free and open Monday-Friday 10am-4pm. You can take an hour-long audio tour on your phone and browse the gift shop.

This article was created with AI assistance and human editing.

Read more from this brand:

• How an enslaved Ghanaian royal became Rhode Island’s legendary “Pastry Queen”
• The Chinese tea house that bankrolled women’s voting rights in America
• The pirate who fooled Rhode Island for 16 years while running his family’s inn