DOJ Still Wants to Keep Switchblades Illegal in 2026

Same Day, Opposite Arguments

On December 22, 2025, the Trump administration filed two legal briefs that left Second Amendment advocates scratching their heads.

In one, the Department of Justice sued Washington, D.C. to overturn its ban on AR-15 rifles. In the other, filed the same day, the DOJ asked a federal appeals court to uphold a 67-year-old ban on switchblade knives.

Knife advocacy groups are furious, and the case now heading to the Fifth Circuit could reshape how courts think about the Second Amendment.

Knife Groups Say DOJ Is Hypocritical

Knife Rights, the advocacy group challenging the federal ban, did not hold back.

Chairman Doug Ritter said the DOJ dumped coal in their stocking with a disappointing brief that continued what he called a Biden-like anti-Second Amendment stance.

He accused the administration of supporting gun rights with one hand while stripping knife rights with the other.

Ritter pointed out that the Second Amendment says arms, not guns, and argued that knives have been weapons for thousands of years before firearms existed.

What the 1958 Law Actually Bans

The Federal Switchblade Act does not make it illegal to own a switchblade in most of America.

Instead, it bans interstate commerce, meaning you cannot legally ship one across state lines or sell one through the mail.

It also prohibits possession on federal lands, U.S. territories, and Native American reservations. If your state allows switchblades and you buy one locally, federal law does not touch you.

But manufacturers cannot sell nationwide, and that restriction has shaped the market for nearly seven decades.

Hollywood Panic Drove Congress to Act

The law traces back to a 1950 magazine article called The Toy That Kills, published in a popular women’s magazine.

The piece painted switchblades as weapons of teenage gang members and sparked a wave of fear. Movies like Rebel Without a Cause and West Side Story cemented the image.

By 1958, Congress was ready to act, even though police data from Kansas City showed only about three dozen switchblade-related incidents in a city of 400,000 people that year.

The Agencies Meant to Enforce It Opposed It

When Congress held hearings in 1958, the two federal agencies that would enforce the law both testified against it. The Department of Justice said it could not recommend the legislation.

The Department of Commerce argued the law would burden law-abiding citizens while accomplishing nothing useful.

A New York senator dismissed their concerns, calling switchblades inherently dangerous and suited only for crime. Congress passed it anyway.

DOJ Calls Switchblades Inherently Criminal

In its December 2025 brief, the Justice Department argued that automatic knives are uniquely suited to criminal misuse because their blades stay concealed until deployment.

Federal lawyers wrote there is no constitutional right to inherently concealed weapons.

They claimed historical tradition supports regulating knives that can be hidden, pointing to 19th-century laws against carrying Bowie knives and dirks.

The DOJ concluded the Switchblade Act fits within that tradition.

That Logic Could Ban Handguns Too

Knife Rights argues the DOJ reasoning is dangerous territory.

If concealment makes a weapon unprotected, what about the Glock 19 or any other pistol designed for concealed carry?

The Supreme Court ruled in 2022 that Americans have a right to carry firearms in public for self-defense.

Ritter said the DOJ logic has already been used by states trying to defend AR-15 bans, and now the same administration is using it against knives while attacking it in gun cases.

Most States Have Already Moved On

Since 2010, Knife Rights has helped repeal switchblade bans or restrictions in more than 20 states. Texas, Pennsylvania, Michigan, and Massachusetts all now allow automatic knives.

In August 2024, the Massachusetts Supreme Court struck down the state ban entirely, ruling it violated the Second Amendment.

Hawaii legalized switchblades in May 2024. The trend is clear at the state level, but the federal law from 1958 remains unchanged on the books.

Gun Groups Are Backing the Knife Fight

Knife Rights is not fighting alone. The National Rifle Association filed an amicus brief in October 2025 urging the Fifth Circuit to reverse the lower court decision.

The Second Amendment Foundation, Firearms Policy Coalition, and Mountain States Legal Foundation all filed supporting briefs.

The NRA argued the district court made a clear legal error by deciding that restrictions on acquiring arms do not fall under the Second Amendment at all.

A District Judge Said the Law Is Dead Anyway

The original lawsuit was dismissed in June 2025 by a federal judge in Texas who concluded the government does not really enforce the Switchblade Act anymore.

The DOJ had argued the plaintiffs lacked standing because prosecutions are rare.

Knife Rights pointed to a 2020 raid where federal agents seized 2.8 million dollars worth of switchblades from a business.

The group refiled with new plaintiffs, including a Native American who cannot legally possess a switchblade in his own home on reservation land.

The Fifth Circuit Could Change Everything

The case is now before the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, and oral arguments have not yet been scheduled.

If the court sides with Knife Rights, it would be the first time a federal appeals court extends full Second Amendment protection to a category of knives.

That would not just affect switchblades.

It could open challenges to gravity knife bans, butterfly knife restrictions, and blade length limits across the country.

The DOJ seems determined to prevent that from happening.

Knives Were Arms Before Guns Existed

The outcome may hinge on a simple question: what counts as an arm? The Second Amendment does not mention firearms specifically.

It protects the right to keep and bear arms, and knives have been used for self-defense since before recorded history.

Knife Rights argues that automatic knives are just a variation of common pocket knives, no more dangerous than any folding blade.

If the courts agree, the 1958 law built on Hollywood fear may finally meet its end.

This article was created with AI assistance and human editing.

Read more from this brand:

• Trump Moves Marijuana Out of the Same Category as Heroin
• National Parks Now Free on Trump’s Birthday; Two Civil Rights Holidays Cut from List
• NYC’s Mamdani Happy to Get Arrested for “The Most American Thing” He Could Do