Connect with us

Texas

Texas education data shows challenges for many Black-majority schools

Published

 

on

Cropped view of people debating.

Texas Education Agency ratings hit home

For Mikole Montgomery, school ratings, academic opportunities, and concerns about resources turned a neighborhood choice into a difficult decision about academics, belonging, and opportunity.

Her 11-year-old son, Jaleel, began sixth grade at the newly opened Amy Coleman Middle School in Fort Bend ISD. His family chose it over the closer Missouri City Middle School, which was rated F in 2025 but improved to a D in the 2026 state accountability ratings. Montgomery has said Missouri City has passionate educators who care about children.

Business review

Texas Education Agency shows a wide gap

The Texas Education Agency uses A through F grades to show how public schools are performing. Ratings consider student achievement, school progress, and closing academic gaps, giving families a clear snapshot while also revealing differences among campuses statewide.

A Texas Tribune analysis of the 2025 ratings found that 35 percent of 302 majority-Black campuses earned a D or F. Only 20 majority-Black campuses received an A, while 105 received D or F grades.

TEA has since released its 2026 ratings, which continue to show lower overall performance among predominantly Black and Hispanic campuses than among majority-white and majority-Asian schools.

Officers analyzing data to study travel trends.

Texas Education Agency grades shape choices

A letter grade on a school profile can carry more weight than it first appears. The Texas Education Agency released its 2026 accountability ratings on August 14, with 85% of rated campuses statewide earning a C or better and 24% improving from the previous year.

A Texas Tribune analysis of the 2025 ratings found that about 60% of majority-Black schools earned a C or better. That share trailed majority-white and majority-Hispanic campuses, while nearly all majority-Asian schools reached the state’s acceptable performance threshold.

Retirement Planning. African American Spouses Having Investment Consultation In Finansial Counselors Office. Selective Focus

One family faces a familiar dilemma

For Montgomery, the choice was not simply between a good school and a bad one. She sees caring educators at Missouri City Middle School and knows neighborhood schools offer friendships, trusted adults, and belonging that ratings alone cannot fully measure.

At the same time, she wants Jaleel to reach programs that could open doors later. Amy Coleman Middle School offers aviation and aerospace learning tied to aerodynamics, aircraft systems, drones, design, and air traffic control, giving students early career exposure.

Education Enrollment Form With Pen Eyeglasses and Office Desk for School Admission Student Registration and Academic Records

Programs can shape a family’s decision

School choice often comes down to what students can explore after entering the building. Fort Bend ISD offers themed middle school programs in aviation, artificial intelligence, creative arts, environmental technology, first responders, and civic leadership at campuses across the district.

Those themes can make schools feel different, even inside one district. A specialized program may offer hands-on projects and career exposure, while a neighborhood campus may provide closer friendships, easier transportation, familiar teachers, and more convenient opportunities for family involvement.

Little-known fact: The U.S. Department of Education reports that millions of students participate in career-focused courses each year, helping them build skills connected to future jobs

Kids studying in a library setting, with stacks of books on a wooden table

A low grade never tells the whole story

A school rating can highlight academic problems, but it cannot describe every classroom, teacher, family, or student experience. Community volunteer Stephanie Brown says Missouri City Middle School has dedicated educators and could improve if students gained stronger programs and resources.

That distinction matters because families may hear an F rating and assume little valuable is happening inside. Parents and educators describe campuses where staff care deeply while handling turnover, limited materials, student mobility, and pressures that can slow academic improvement.

People sitting and attending a seminar.

Resources shape what classrooms can offer

Schools do not operate with identical advantages, even when the same accountability scale measures them. Education researchers point to funding, rigorous courses, staffing, and community partnerships as factors that can shape student experiences long before test scores become letter grades.

A campus with active parent groups or business partners may gain extra learning opportunities. When leaders spend time filling staff gaps, finding materials, or handling urgent student needs, they may have less time for teacher coaching, advanced classes, and planning.

African American teacher working on laptop

Teacher representation can matter

Who stands at the front of the classroom can influence more than student comfort. Research has linked Black teacher representation with positive outcomes for Black students, including stronger academic performance and engagement, while studies find broader benefits across student groups.

Parents may value teachers who understand cultural references, community expectations, and experiences their children recognize. That does not mean students can learn only from teachers sharing their race, but it helps explain why representation can matter when families compare schools.

Little-known fact: Research reviewed by the Learning Policy Institute found evidence that Black teachers can have positive effects on Black students’ academic outcomes.

Close up of attendance record sheet with empty copy space.

Leaving can create a financial ripple

When families move children away from struggling neighborhood schools, the effect can reach beyond one empty desk. Texas school finance uses average daily attendance in funding calculations, so falling attendance can add pressure to campuses already trying to improve support.

There is also a less visible loss when active families leave a campus. Schools may lose parents who volunteer, organize events, advocate for resources, and strengthen community ties, creating a cycle where fewer families remain to expand opportunities for students.

Government officials at a legislative session.

Low ratings bring pressure to improve

Texas evaluates thousands of campuses through its accountability system, and low grades can bring stronger attention from districts and the state. The Texas Tribune reported that roughly 15 percent of evaluated schools received the lowest grades in ratings it analyzed.

For school leaders, that pressure can quickly shape daily priorities. Former principals told the Tribune they balanced academic improvement with staff departures, funding cuts, morale, student mobility, and immediate needs, showing why raising a campus grade involves more than testing.

old-fashioned elementary school report card

State leaders defend accountability

Texas Education Commissioner Mike Morath argues that ratings help identify schools needing faster changes and stronger leadership. The agency describes the A through F system as a transparency tool built around student achievement, school progress, and performance gaps among groups.

Statewide results also show that school grades can improve over time. In 2025, the Texas Education Agency reported that 31 percent of campuses improved their letter grade from the previous year.

children at school performing on stage in front of parents

Community support offers another path

Not every parent believes leaving a neighborhood campus is the best answer. Stephanie Brown has helped connect students with an engineering camp at Prairie View A&M University, where people can experience robotics, computer science, and campus life during summers.

Her approach reflects a broader idea: bringing opportunities directly to local students. Tutoring, after-school programs, advanced classes, career experiences, and community partnerships can make neighborhood campuses stronger while showing children that their ZIP code should not limit what they explore.

Texas’ power needs are growing fast, but not everyone agrees on the solution. Find out why lawmakers and residents are divided over this proposed transmission plan.

View of a parent-teacher meeting.

The decision is bigger than one letter

For parents, school ratings can be useful, but they are only one part of a larger decision. Families may also weigh safety, teacher quality, course choices, transportation, friendships, school culture, activities, special programs, and how supported their child feels daily.

Jaleel’s move to a new aviation-focused school shows how personal those tradeoffs can become. His family chose wider academic opportunities while still worrying about the neighborhood school left behind, a tension shared by parents seeking options without abandoning their community.

The conversation around safety and privacy is growing. Discover what is driving the pushback against expanding license plate surveillance across Texas.

What do you think Texas schools need most to help every student succeed? Share your thoughts in the comments.

This slideshow was made with AI assistance and human editing.

Read More From This Brand:

Currently residing in the "Sunset State" with his wife and 8 pound Pomeranian. Leo is a lover of all things travel related outside and inside the United States. Leo has been to every continent and continues to push to reach his goals of visiting every country someday. Learn more about Leo on Muck Rack.

Trending Posts