This 1855 revenge attack on peaceful Lakota families began with a hungry warrior eating the wrong cow

Chester Nimitz’s Career-Saving Court-Martial and Submarine Destiny

The Admiral Nimitz Gallery at the National Museum of the Pacific War tells the story of how one young officer’s biggest mistake became his greatest strength.

On July 7, 1908, 23-year-old Ensign Chester Nimitz ran his destroyer aground in the Philippines after forgetting to check the tide tables. A court martial found him guilty and stripped him of command.

The Navy punished him with submarine duty, which seemed like career suicide at the time. But those four years underwater made Nimitz one of America’s best submarine experts.

That expertise helped him crush Japan’s navy thirty-five years later. This is how a mudbank mishap created a Pacific war hero.

Young Officer Ran His Ship Aground in the Philippines

On July 7, 1908, Ensign Chester Nimitz made a mistake that nearly ended his naval career. The 23-year-old officer ran the destroyer USS Decatur onto a mudbank near Batangas Harbor in the Philippines.

Nimitz didn’t check the harbor’s tide tables before entering shallow waters. He tried to guess his position instead of taking proper bearings in the darkness.

Though he sent a sailor to check water depth, Nimitz never got the report. At 9:52 PM, the 420-ton destroyer got stuck about one and a half miles from Batangas Light.

The Crew Spent a Long Night Stuck in the Mud

The crew tried everything to free the ship through the night, but nothing worked. Nimitz could have hidden the grounding from his bosses or downplayed what happened.

Instead, he wrote honest log entries that showed exactly what went wrong. These truthful notes later became evidence against him at his court-martial.

When morning came, a passing commercial steamboat helped pull Decatur free from the mud.

Naval Authorities Quickly Put Nimitz on Trial

A naval board looked into the grounding right away. They charged Nimitz with "doing his job poorly" and listed nine specific mistakes.

The court-martial started just three weeks after the incident aboard the USS Denver at Cavite Naval Base. Four commanders, two lieutenant commanders, and one lieutenant made up the court.

Lieutenant Ralph Earle worked as the prosecutor, gathering evidence to show Nimitz had been careless.

His Own Logbook Became the Key Evidence

Earle used Nimitz’s honest logbook entries against him during the trial. The young officer’s own words showed he had made serious navigation mistakes.

Crew members from the Decatur told the court about the failures that led to the grounding. Nimitz hadn’t mapped out visibility arcs for navigation lights.

He also didn’t take bearings on fixed red lights while approaching the harbor.

The Court Showed Mercy to the Promising Officer

The court found Nimitz guilty but gave him a lighter punishment than expected. He got a "public reprimand" rather than getting kicked out of the Navy.

Nimitz lost command of the USS Decatur right after the trial.

The admiral who reviewed his service record wrote, "This is a good officer and will take more care in the future. " The court members saw potential in the young sailor despite his serious mistake.

The Navy Sent Him to the Submarine Service

When Nimitz returned to the United States, he got new orders in January 1909. The Navy sent him to submarine service, which most officers saw as punishment.

Back then, submarine duty seemed dangerous work that didn’t help advance careers. Young officers thought submarine service put crews at more risk than it posed to enemies.

Nimitz felt unsure about this new job and saw it as part of his punishment for the grounding.

Nimitz Took Command of a Primitive Underwater Vessel

Nimitz started submarine training at Newport, Rhode Island in January 1909. By May 3 that same year, he took command of USS Plunger, an early gasoline-powered submarine.

He thought it looked like "a cross between a Jules Verne fantasy and a humpbacked whale" when he first saw it. Despite his doubts, Nimitz also became Commander of the First Submarine Torpedo Flotilla.

USS Plunger served as his first flagship, though his "flotilla" had just one other submarine.

He Became an Expert in Dangerous New Technology

Over the next four years, Nimitz commanded several submarines including Snapper and Narwhal. He quickly saw how underwater warfare could change naval battles despite his early doubts.

Nimitz grew into one of the most knowledgeable submarine officers in the fleet. He learned to run vessels with gasoline engines and later helped change them to safer diesel power.

The once-reluctant submariner became a strong supporter of underwater naval technology.

Nimitz Created Revolutionary Naval Tactics

Starting in 1917, Nimitz created new ways to refuel and resupply ships while at sea. These methods later let American ships stay far from port during World War II.

He became the Navy’s top expert on submarine operations and technology. His knowledge covered engines, battle tactics, and crew training.

By 1939, Nimitz had moved up to become Chief of the Bureau of Navigation. The skills from his "punishment" job prepared him for the biggest challenge of his career.

He Took Command of the Pacific Fleet on a Submarine

On December 31, 1941, Admiral Nimitz took command of the Pacific Fleet in a meaningful location. He raised his flag aboard the submarine USS Grayling instead of on a battleship or carrier.

This choice showed both his submarine background and the tough situation at Pearl Harbor. Most warships were either sunk or heading to the West Coast for repairs after the Japanese attack.

Nimitz raised his four-star flag on Grayling’s mast, taking control of what would grow into history’s largest naval force.

The Court-Martialed Ensign Became America’s Greatest Admiral

Nimitz’s submarine knowledge proved essential during the Battle of Midway in June 1942. His understanding of undersea warfare helped create the strategy that defeated the Japanese fleet.

The court-martial that nearly ended his career had pushed him toward the expertise that won the war. Fleet Admiral Nimitz led the most successful submarine campaign in naval history.

On September 2, 1945, he signed Japan’s surrender documents aboard USS Missouri in Tokyo Bay. The young officer who ran his ship aground had become the architect of America’s greatest naval victory.

Visiting the Admiral Nimitz Gallery at the National Museum of the Pacific War

The Admiral Nimitz Gallery at the National Museum of the Pacific War is at 328 E Main Street in Fredericksburg, Texas. General admission costs $24 for adults, with discounts for seniors, military, and students.

The museum is open Wednesday through Monday from 9am to 5pm. Your ticket includes the Submarine Exhibit and other Pacific War displays.

Buy tickets online up to four weeks ahead since they’re recommended.

This article was created with AI assistance and human editing.

Read more from this brand:

• How one WWII battleship’s crew flooded their own ship to keep killing Germans beyond their gun range
• Coahuiltecan tribes finally got legal land rights in 1731 San Antonio, Texas. It was stolen from them four days later.
• How Lyndon B. Johnson turned his cattle ranch into America’s unofficial White House with BBQ diplomacy