Connect with us

USA

$12,000 payday for American families may be possible with propose law

Published

 

on

Closeup of hands holding cash

New bill targets billionaire wealth directly

Sen. Bernie Sanders of Vermont and Rep. Ro Khanna of California introduced the Make Billionaires Pay Their Fair Share Act on March 2. The bill would create a 5% yearly tax on every American worth $1 billion or more.

In its first year, that money would fund $3,000 payments to every person in households earning $150,000 or less. For a family of four, that comes to $12,000.

The estimated cost of those payments alone is about $959 billion.

Businessman flying on his private jet. Successful business man and entrepreneur flying to his meeting. Famous salesman and speaker going to a sales event

Only 938 Americans would owe the tax

The tax would hit 938 billionaires who together hold about $8.2 trillion in wealth. Nobody worth less than $1 billion would pay a dime more.

And unlike regular income taxes, this one targets total wealth, including stocks, real estate, and other assets, not just what someone earns in a given year.

Sanders and Khanna say the tax would barely dent these fortunes while making a real difference for working families across the country.

U.S. AIR FORCE ACADEMY, Colo. -- Tesla Inc. Chief Executive Officer Elon Musk speaks with Lt. Gen. Richard Clark, Superintendent of the U.S. Air Force Academy, during the Ira C. Eaker Distinguished Speaker Presentation in the Academy's Arnold Hall on April 7, 2022 in Colorado Springs, Colo.

Musk alone would owe about $42 billion

The numbers get eye-popping fast. Elon Musk, worth an estimated $833 billion, would owe roughly $42 billion under the proposal, leaving him with about $792 billion.

Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg, worth about $220 billion, would owe around $11 billion. Amazon founder Jeff Bezos, also worth roughly $218 billion, would face a similar bill.

Even after paying, all three would remain among the richest people on the planet.

Close up Franklin's face on a one hundred dollar. American, US Dollars Cash Money background

Economists disagree on how much it raises

UC Berkeley economists Emmanuel Saez and Gabriel Zucman estimate the tax would bring in about $4.4 trillion over 10 years. But not everyone buys that number.

The American Enterprise Institute says the real figure could be less than half, because the estimate doesn’t fully account for how billionaires would avoid paying.

Tax Foundation senior fellow Jared Walczak also questioned whether the projection reflects real-world economic effects. The gap between those estimates is wide.

Moscow, Moscow region, Russia - 03.09.2023: Modern hospital room with unoccupied beds and sunlit curtains

The bill would fund health care and housing too

Direct payments are just the start. The bill also calls for reversing about $1.1 trillion in cuts to Medicaid and the Affordable Care Act from the One Big Beautiful Bill Act.

It would expand Medicare to cover dental, vision, and hearing for seniors. On top of that, it proposes building, fixing, and preserving more than 7 million affordable homes.

It would cap childcare costs at 7% of a family’s income and set a $60,000 minimum salary for all public school teachers.

Washington DC. Congress and Senate. US Capitol

Republicans control Congress, so odds are slim

The bill faces virtually no chance of becoming law right now. Republicans control both the House and Senate.

Multiple news outlets described the proposal as dead on arrival in the current Congress. Several analysts see it more as a political statement than a serious legislative push.

That doesn’t mean the idea disappears, though. Bills like this often set the stage for future campaigns and policy debates.

US election day, Diverse people at voting booth at US election station with American flag in background. Diverse people in line to vote at US election day. Vote for American democracy

The bill could shape the 2028 race

Some political observers think the bill is really about 2028.

Reports suggest it could become a test for Democratic presidential candidates, much like Sanders’ Medicare-for-all plan did during the 2020 cycle.

Khanna himself has been named as a possible 2028 presidential contender.

The wealth tax idea has broad public support, with roughly two-thirds of Americans backing it in polls. That kind of popularity makes it a powerful campaign tool.

Capitol building on Capitol Hill in Washington, DC, symbol of democracy and US government

Congress has never passed a wealth tax

This isn’t the first time lawmakers have tried. Sanders has introduced similar wealth tax bills in past sessions of Congress.

The Biden administration proposed a 20% minimum income tax on households worth $100 million or more in 2023, and it went nowhere. No federal wealth tax has ever become law in the United States.

The pattern is clear: these proposals draw attention, spark debate, and then stall out in Congress.

Hands holding fan of hundred-dollar bills, highlighting wealth and currency

California fights its own billionaire tax battle

A separate fight is playing out in California. A state ballot initiative would impose a one-time 5% tax on billionaires living there.

That proposal has already triggered high-profile exits, with Google co-founders Sergey Brin and Larry Page among those who announced plans to leave.

Gov. Gavin Newsom has opposed the measure, warning it would drive companies and wealthy residents away. Sanders traveled to California in February to campaign for the state initiative.

Financial chart with downward arrow showing negative trend and magnifier

Legal experts split on whether it’s constitutional

Even if a wealth tax passed Congress, it might not survive the courts. Legal scholars disagree on whether the Constitution allows it.

The Constitution says direct taxes must be split among states based on population, which could make a wealth tax unworkable in practice. Supporters argue Congress has broad enough taxing power to make it legal.

Opponents say current rulings would likely strike it down. This unresolved legal question is one big reason no federal wealth tax has ever passed.

Plus and Minus symbols on US dollar banknotes representing Federal Reserve interest rate changes

Both sides make their case loudly

Sanders argued that 60% of Americans live paycheck to paycheck while 938 billionaires grew $1.5 trillion richer.

Khanna said taxing billionaires “a modest amount can give everyone a fair chance” while keeping the country’s innovative engine running.

Critics warn the tax could reduce investment, slow economic growth, and push wealthy Americans to find ways around it.

Saez and Zucman said the U.S. has reached record levels of wealth concentration that the tax would help address.

Lawsuit form with filler and book

No checks are coming anytime soon

Here’s the bottom line: this bill is a proposal, and it’s not expected to become law under the current Congress. No payments are coming based on this bill in its current form.

If a similar measure ever passed in the future, it could change taxes, government programs, and direct payments to households. For now, readers should be cautious about any headlines suggesting checks are on the way.

The idea is alive, but the legislation is not moving.

This article was created with AI assistance and human editing.

Read more from this brand:

John Ghost is a professional writer and SEO director. He graduated from Arizona State University with a BA in English (Writing, Rhetorics, and Literacies). As he prepares for graduate school to become an English professor, he writes weird fiction, plays his guitars, and enjoys spending time with his wife and daughters. He lives in the Valley of the Sun. Learn more about John on Muck Rack.

Trending Posts