Social Security Gets a Historic Raise in 2026 But Retirees Will Still Lose Money

Trump Tariffs Helped Boost the Numbers

Social Security checks are going up 2.8% in January 2026, adding about $56 per month to the average retiree’s benefit.

The raise sounds good on paper, and it even sets a record: it’s the first time in nearly 30 years that benefits have climbed by at least 2.5% for five straight years.

But between rising Medicare premiums and the actual cost of groceries, housing, and healthcare, most retirees will end up with less buying power than they have today.

The tariffs that helped push inflation higher are the same ones that will keep pushing prices up.

Five Straight Years of 2.5% or Higher

The 2026 COLA continues a streak not seen since the Clinton administration.

From 2022 through 2026, benefits rose 5.9%, 8.7%, 3.2%, 2.5%, and now 2.8%. That brings the five-year average to 4.6%, the highest since 1986.

For retirees, this sounds like welcome news after years of tiny adjustments. In 2016, the COLA was just 0.3%. In 2010, 2011, and 2015, there was no raise at all.

But the recent string of higher COLAs came because prices were rising fast, not because the government got more generous.

Tariffs Pushed Inflation Higher

President Trump’s baseline 10% tariff on imports took effect in April 2025. Since then, inflation measured by the CPI-W climbed from 2.1% to 2.9%.

Higher prices mean higher inflation readings, and higher inflation means a bigger COLA. Economists call it a “Trump bump.”

But the same tariffs that boosted the COLA are also making everyday goods more expensive, so retirees are paying more at the same time they’re getting more.

How the Government Calculates the Raise

The Social Security Administration doesn’t just pick a number.

By law, the COLA is tied to the Consumer Price Index for Urban Wage Earners and Clerical Workers, measured during the third quarter.

The agency compares average prices from July through September 2025 against the same months in 2024.

That comparison showed a 2.8% increase, so benefits go up 2.8%. The formula is automatic and has been since 1975.

Congress doesn’t vote on it, and the president doesn’t approve it.

Medicare Takes a Big Bite First

Before retirees see that extra $56, Medicare Part B takes its cut. The monthly premium is jumping from $185 to $202.90, a 9.7% increase and the largest since 2022.

That $17. 90 comes straight out of Social Security checks for most beneficiaries. After Medicare, the average retiree keeps about $38 of the raise.

The Part B deductible is also climbing from $257 to $283. For someone who ends up in the hospital, the Part A deductible rises $60 to $1,736.

The Wrong Yardstick for Retirees

The CPI-W was designed to track prices for working-age urban households, not retirees. It assumes people spend about 42% of their budget on housing and 7% on medical care.

But seniors typically spend more on both, especially healthcare. When those categories rise faster than overall inflation, retirees feel it more than the COLA reflects.

The Bureau of Labor Statistics has an experimental index called the CPI-E that weights spending the way people 62 and older actually spend.

It usually runs higher than the CPI-W.

Benefits Lost 20% of Value Since 2010

According to research from the Senior Citizens League, Social Security benefits have lost about 20% of their purchasing power since 2010.

To make up the gap, the average retiree would need an extra $370 per month.

Eight of the last fifteen COLAs failed to keep pace with inflation for the year they were paid. The problem is cumulative.

A retiree who claimed benefits in 2010 has watched prices rise faster than their checks for most of the years since.

Housing Costs Squeeze Senior Budgets

Home prices and property taxes have risen 89% since 2010.

For seniors on fixed incomes, that means either paying more to stay in homes they own or facing higher rents if they don’t.

Housing makes up nearly half of the typical senior’s budget according to the CPI-E weights. The shelter component of inflation rose 3.6% over the past year.

When you spend more of your income on something, price increases in that category hurt more than the overall average suggests.

Medical Care Keeps Climbing Faster

Healthcare costs rose 3.3% over the past year, outpacing the 2.8% COLA. Seniors spend two to three times more of their budgets on medical care than younger workers do.

Medicare Part B premiums, prescription drugs, dental care, and supplemental insurance all add up. The Senior Citizens League found that Medicare Part B premiums alone have risen 195% since 2000.

Out-of-pocket prescription costs jumped 188% over the same period. The COLA formula doesn’t fully capture these expenses.

An Alternative Formula Exists

If Social Security used the CPI-E instead of the CPI-W, the 2026 COLA would have been 3% instead of 2.8%.

That’s an extra $4 per month for the average retiree, or $48 per year. Over a 25-year retirement, small differences compound.

Some Democratic lawmakers have introduced bills to switch to the CPI-E or use whichever index is higher in a given year.

Critics argue that boosting COLAs would drain the Social Security trust fund faster. The fund is already projected to run short by the mid-2030s.

More Price Increases Are Coming

Retailers absorbed some tariff costs in 2025 by drawing down inventory and accepting lower margins. That cushion is running out.

Economists at Goldman Sachs and the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis expect businesses to pass more costs to consumers in 2026.

Any price increases after September 2025 won’t show up in the COLA until 2027. Retirees will pay higher prices for months before their checks catch up.

The same tariffs that boosted this year’s raise will keep pushing prices higher, and the formula will always be looking backward.

The Raise Helps But Doesn’t Fix the Problem

The 2.8% COLA means about $56 more per month before Medicare premiums.

After Part B takes its cut, the average retiree keeps roughly $38. That’s better than nothing, and the five-year streak of decent raises is historically unusual.

But it’s not a windfall. It’s an adjustment designed to help benefits keep pace with rising costs, and by most measures, it’s still falling short.

Retirees who feel like they have a little less money each year aren’t imagining it.

This article was created with AI assistance and human editing.

Read more from this brand:

• You Need at Least $1 Million to Retire in These 13 States
• Trump Admin Wants You to Stop Visiting Social Security Offices
• The USA is Entering a Golden Age, Trump Tells McDonald’s Franchisees as Company Continues to Lose Budget Diners