These cruise ships often get some of the roughest reviews

Cruise ships that missed the mark

Dreaming of sunny decks, endless buffets, and ocean views? Most cruises promise a floating resort packed with fun. But not every ship lives up to the glossy photos in the brochure.

Some travelers step off feeling relaxed and refreshed. Others leave wishing they had picked a different sailing. Online reviews tell very different stories depending on the ship.

Before you book that long-awaited getaway, it helps to know which ships have drawn steady complaints. Here are nine cruise ships that many guests say fell short of expectations.

MSC Lirica left guests unimpressed

The MSC Lirica first set sail in 2003 and is one of the older ships in the MSC fleet. Age alone is not the issue. Many classic ships still offer great trips when well-maintained and updated.

Travelers on CruiseCritic often mention average food and slow service. Some guests say staff members were polite but not especially attentive. That can make a long voyage feel less special.

Entertainment options also get mixed feedback. Guests looking for lively activities and fresh onboard experiences sometimes say they felt limited in their options. Reviews often hover around three out of five stars.

MSC Armonia shows its age

MSC Armonia is another early 2000s ship that has struggled to impress recent passengers. As one of the oldest ships in the MSC lineup, it has faced tough comparisons with newer vessels.

Guests often point to dated décor and worn common areas. Cleanliness has also been raised as a concern in some reviews, which no one wants to think about at sea.

Food and service receive mixed ratings as well. Some cruisers say meals lacked variety, while others felt staff were hard to reach during busy times. Ratings frequently land near the middle of the scale.

MSC Preziosa disappoints expectations

Built in 2013, MSC Preziosa looks modern from the outside. Many travelers expected it to stand out as a highlight of the fleet. Instead, reviews suggest a less polished experience.

Common complaints focus on dining. Guests report that food arrives lukewarm or lacks flavor. Long waits in dining rooms and busy buffet lines also appear in online feedback.

Customer service reviews are uneven. Some passengers report helpful crew members, while others say issues were not resolved quickly. On CruiseCritic, average ratings often sit around three stars.

Magellan struggled in later years

The Magellan, operated by Cruise and Maritime Voyages, originally launched in 1985. By the time it stopped sailing in 2020, it had served for decades across various cruise lines.

Many travelers appreciated its classic feel, but others felt it showed clear signs of wear. Reviews mention outdated cabins and fewer onboard amenities than on newer ships.

Food quality and entertainment also drew criticism from some guests. While average ratings hovered around three stars, several reviews suggest the overall value did not always match the ticket price.

Carnival Sunrise felt overcrowded

Carnival Sunrise has drawn frequent complaints about crowding and long lines, especially around pools and buffets, but recent aggregated ratings on some booking platforms sit in the good (around 4/5) range.

Passengers often describe long lines for popular attractions and dining spots. During peak sailings, public areas can feel packed, making it harder to relax.

Cleanliness and basic service generally receive decent marks. The main issue appears to be capacity and wait times. For travelers who value space and shorter lines, this ship may feel overwhelming.

Costa Deliziosa drew steady complaints

Costa Deliziosa sails under Costa Cruises, a brand owned by Carnival Corporation. While the ship remains active, reviews show consistent concerns from guests over the years.

Food quality is a frequent topic. Some passengers say meals lacked flavor or arrived at the wrong temperature. Others mention limited menu variety during longer sailings.

Service also receives mixed reactions. A few travelers describe friendly staff, but others felt their concerns were not handled promptly. Overall ratings on review sites often settle in the lower middle range.

Costa Fascinosa fell short for many

Costa Fascinosa was designed with bold interiors and dramatic themes. On paper, it promises an exciting atmosphere. In practice, some guests say the experience did not match the look.

Repetitive dining options are a common complaint. Several reviews mention seeing the same dishes appear multiple times during the trip. That can be disappointing on a vacation meant to feel special.

Service reviews are also mixed. Some cruisers felt staff seemed stretched thin during busy periods. Online ratings often fall below average compared to other ships in its class.

Costa Favolosa missed the magic

Costa Favolosa has an eye-catching design and modern features. At first glance, it appears ready to deliver a memorable getaway. Guest feedback tells a more complicated story.

Travelers frequently comment on inconsistent dining experiences. Some say meals were enjoyable, while others felt options were limited or poorly prepared. Cleanliness in certain areas has also been questioned in reviews.

Customer service is a sticking point for some passengers. Reports of slow response times to requests have affected overall satisfaction, resulting in lower average ratings on cruise review platforms.

Costa Venezia faced harsh ratings

Costa Venezia, delivered in 2019 as Costa’s first ship purpose-built for Chinese guests, initially drew harsh reviews about food, queues, and service. Today, she sails as Carnival Venezia for Carnival Cruise Line, so newer reviews reflect that updated experience.

Despite its modern build, some reviews point to issues with food quality and long wait times for beverages and dining. Crowded public spaces are also mentioned by guests on busy sailings.

On CruiseCritic, Costa Venezia has received particularly low average ratings compared to similar ships. For many reviewers, the service and onboard experience did not match the ship’s fresh appearance.

Why online reviews matter

Cruise reviews give real insight from people who have actually sailed on these ships. Sites like CruiseCritic allow guests to rate cabins, dining, service, and entertainment in detail.

Of course, not every review tells the full story. Experiences can vary by itinerary, season, and even cabin location. Still, consistent patterns across hundreds of reviews are worth noting.

When a ship regularly earns low marks for the same issues, it signals a concern. Reading a range of opinions can help you avoid unpleasant surprises once you are out at sea.

Older ships need extra care

Many ships on this list were built in the early 2000s or even the 1980s. Older vessels can still offer great trips if they receive strong maintenance and timely upgrades.

Without updates, cabins may feel dated, and public areas can show wear. Guests often compare older ships to the newest mega ships packed with high-tech features.

Refurbishments can make a major difference. Before booking, check the renovation date and look at recent traveler photos. That can give a clearer picture of what to expect on board.

Wondering why Hawaii suddenly blocked its cruise tax and how it affects travelers? Have a look.

How to choose a better cruise

Start by setting your top priorities. Some travelers care most about dining, while others focus on spacious cabins or exciting activities. Knowing what matters to you makes research easier.

Look at recent reviews, not just overall star ratings. Pay attention to comments from sailings within the past year. Ships can improve or decline over time.

Finally, compare ships within the same price range. A lower fare may explain fewer amenities. Taking a few extra minutes to research can help you book a cruise that truly feels like a vacation.

Curious which popular item Disney Cruise Line will be confiscating next year and why? Explore the details.

Have you ever sailed on one of these ships, or would you still give it a try? Share your experience in the comments.

This slideshow was made with AI assistance and human editing.

Read More From This Brand:

• US steps in on Hawaii’s cruise ship tax dispute
• Best September scenic boat cruises in the US
• 13 Everyday Activities That Are Actually Illegal in US National Parks