Connect with us

Utah

Congress kills Echo Park: the 1956 vote that saved Utah canyons

Published

 

on

David Brower’s Dam Fight That Sparked Environmentalism

Dinosaur National Monument in Utah almost disappeared under 400 feet of water in the 1950s.

The Bureau of Reclamation wanted to build a massive dam at Echo Park that would flood the spectacular canyons where the Green and Yampa rivers meet.

Most people had never seen this remote wilderness, including Sierra Club members who called it wasteland. Then David Brower showed up with rafts, cameras, and a plan.

He organized river trips, published a book, and built a coalition that stopped the dam through pure political warfare. Congress killed the project in 1956, but Brower had to sacrifice Glen Canyon to save Dinosaur.

The battle that launched modern environmentalism played out right where you can raft today.

Bureau of Reclamation Wanted to Build a Dam at Echo Park

The Bureau of Reclamation spotted Echo Park as a perfect dam location in the 1930s. They planned to build a 529-foot concrete dam about 2 miles below where the Green and Yampa rivers meet.

The planned lake would hold 6. 4 million acre-feet of water and flood the Canyon of Lodore, Browns Park, and Yampa River valley to Lily Park.

Water would cover half of Steamboat Rock, plus many caves, ancient sites, and wild valleys throughout the monument.

DeVoto’s Magazine Article Got Americans Fired Up

Bernard DeVoto changed the game when he wrote “Shall We Let Them Ruin Our National Parks? ” in The Saturday Evening Post on July 22, 1950.

His article told Americans that Echo Park’s beautiful rock formations would end up underwater and ruin Dinosaur National Monument forever. People started talking after reading it.

When Reader’s Digest printed the article again in November 1951, millions more Americans read it, turning a local issue into a national cause making headlines everywhere.

Home Movies Showed Sierra Club the Beauty They’d Missed

Most Sierra Club members ignored Dinosaur National Monument as worthless empty land at first.

Everything changed in 1952 when a club member showed home movies that caught the stunning beauty of the monument’s hidden canyons.

The films made David Brower and other members realize they had missed something truly special.

Brower became Sierra Club’s first executive director that same year and jumped right into the fight to stop the Echo Park Dam.

Rafting Trips Let People See the Monument’s Value

Sierra Club began taking people rafting on the Green River through Dinosaur National Monument in 1953.

Brower took his sons on a 50-mile trip down the Yampa River, passing green slopes ending at the massive Steamboat Rock. These group float trips in 1953 and 1954 showed doubters that river running was safe and fun.

As more visitors saw the amazing river canyons themselves, more people fought against the dam.

Stegner’s Book Went Straight to Congress

David Brower asked writer Wallace Stegner to create a book about the monument.

They quickly printed “This is Dinosaur” with publisher Alfred Knopf in 1955, right during the heated dam debate. They sent copies to every member of Congress to defend why the monument should stay untouched.

The book had essays from top experts covering geology, wildlife, ancient cultures, and natural resources.

Conservation Groups Teamed Up for the First Time

David Brower of Sierra Club and Howard Zahniser of the Wilderness Society led a nationwide campaign that brought together groups that never worked together before.

The Audubon Society, Izaak Walton League, and many smaller conservation groups joined forces. Famous writers and politicians also fought against the dam.

Conservation leaders asked their members to get involved, sending hundreds of letters to Washington offices. This marked the first time so many environmental groups united for one cause.

Math Errors Came to Light During a Congress Hearing

At a January 1954 House hearing, David Brower felt nervous as he got ready to speak. Using simple math and a chalkboard, he showed big mistakes in the Bureau’s water loss calculations.

The Bureau claimed Echo Park and a low Glen Canyon dam would save 165,000 acre-feet of water yearly compared to other options. Brower’s math showed the real difference was only 19,000 acre-feet.

Three months later, the Bureau admitted their math was wrong.

Glen Canyon Became the Backup Nobody Really Wanted

Brower pushed Glen Canyon as another dam site that could store water while keeping Dinosaur National Monument safe. The Bureau of Reclamation backed away from Echo Park in 1954 after their math errors came out.

Conservation groups found surprise allies in California lawmakers who opposed the entire Colorado River Storage Project for their own reasons.

As talks moved forward, Echo Park Dam got dropped and replaced with plans for Glen Canyon Dam.

Lawmakers Gave In to Growing Public Pressure

Upper basin lawmakers met in Denver and reluctantly agreed to remove Echo Park dam from the Colorado River Storage Project in late 1955.

Environmental groups had threatened to fight the entire upper-basin project if Echo Park stayed in the plan.

Congress didn’t want to test whether conservationists were bluffing, so they finally gave in and dropped Echo Park as a dam site.

Bernard DeVoto died on November 13, 1955, just one month before Interior Secretary McKay announced that Echo Park had been eliminated from the project.

The Price of Victory Left a Bitter Taste

David Brower later called the Glen Canyon compromise the “worst mistake of his career” and the “biggest sin I ever committed.” Shortly after the decision, Brower visited Glen Canyon and realized it was no place for a reservoir either.

Howard Zahniser and the Wilderness Society built on the coalition’s newfound confidence to push for a national wilderness preservation system.

The Echo Park victory became a turning point in American environmental history, marking the moment when the environmental movement emerged as a real political force.

But the flooding of Glen Canyon remained a painful reminder of what was lost in the bargain.

Visiting Dinosaur National Monument, Utah

You can explore Echo Park, the heart of David Brower’s famous dam battle, for $25 per vehicle (valid seven days).

Getting there requires a high-clearance vehicle for the 12-mile unpaved Echo Park Road, which starts 25 miles north of Canyon Visitor Center on Harpers Corner Road.

Camp at Echo Park’s 22 sites with firepits and vault toilets, or hike Harpers Corner Trail for views 2,500 feet above the preserved valley.

This article was created with AI assistance and human editing.

John Ghost is a professional writer and SEO director. He graduated from Arizona State University with a BA in English (Writing, Rhetorics, and Literacies). As he prepares for graduate school to become an English professor, he writes weird fiction, plays his guitars, and enjoys spending time with his wife and daughters. He lives in the Valley of the Sun. Learn more about John on Muck Rack.

Trending Posts