How World War II killed an isolated, self-sufficient Appalachian community on Cumberland Mountain

Sherman Hensley’s 48-Year Mountain Settlement at Cumberland Gap

In 1903, Sherman and Nicey Hensley packed their lives onto a mule-drawn sled and climbed Brush Mountain to start fresh. Their tiny log cabin grew into a world apart from modern America.

Soon after, Willy and Nancy Gibbons joined them, and by 1925, nearly 100 people lived in this hidden community. Without roads, power, or plumbing, they built 45 structures and made everything by hand.

The settlement slowly died as young folks left for war and coal mines until 1951, when 70-year-old Sherman walked away for good.

The restored Hensley Settlement at Cumberland Gap National Historic Park now stands frozen in time, waiting for you to step back into mountain life as it once was.

Burton Hensley Sr. Divided 500 Mountain Acres Among His Family

Burton Hensley Sr. bought 500 acres on Brush Mountain in May 1903.

He split the land into 16 parcels for his family members. His daughter Nicey Ann got 21 acres, and her husband Sherman quickly bought another 33 acres.

The land wasn’t totally wild, as renters John Nichols and Jim Nelson had already cleared parts for their animals.

The property came with chestnut log cabins with shake roofs and fields ready for farming. Governor William Owsley first gave away the land back in 1845.

A Pregnant Nicey Ann Traveled Up the Mountain by Mule-Drawn Sled

Sherman and Nicey Ann Hensley moved to their log cabin in December 1903. Nicey was three months pregnant with their second child during the tough winter trip.

They loaded everything onto a sled pulled by a mule. They brought all their animals too: a gray mare, two heifers, a calf, and about 18 hogs.

Sherman raised hogs and wanted the mountain plateau for a simple life. The remote spot also helped them avoid tax men looking for moonshine in the valleys below.

Willy and Nancy Gibbons Became the Second Founding Family

Nancy Gibbons, Nicey’s niece, moved to the settlement with her husband Willy in 1904, who worked together to build the mountain community.

These two families formed the heart of what grew into a 48-year experiment in mountain living. They started with the basics: log cabins, cleared fields, and springs for water.

Both families quickly got to work cutting more trees and putting up new buildings as more people joined them.

Residents Built Everything From Grist Mills to Moonshine Stills

The community built 45 buildings in all, including log cabins, a blacksmith shop, and a sorghum mill. Families grew, raised, and made everything they needed without modern tools.

They built two water-powered grist mills to grind corn and other grains. A spring house used cold mountain water to keep food fresh.

Several moonshine stills ran around the edges of the settlement, giving families their main source of cash. The community truly lived off the land on top of the mountain.

The County Sent a Teacher After Families Built a Schoolhouse

Sherman Hensley and Willy Gibbons went down to Pineville to ask Bell County officials for a teacher in 1908. The county boss agreed but told them they needed a proper school building first.

The families quickly built a simple “lean-to” structure near Chimney Rocks for their first schoolhouse. The one-room school taught kids through eighth grade.

Over the settlement’s 48 years, four different buildings served as the Brush Mountain School before it closed in 1947.

The Mountain Community Peaked at 100 People in 1925

The settlement grew to about 100 residents by 1925, mostly Hensley and Gibbons family members. They lived totally cut off from modern life, without electricity, roads, indoor toilets, or phones.

People got around only by walking or riding horses on rough trails. Men usually left the mountain once a month to sell moonshine and trade for supplies they couldn’t make.

Women and children rarely went down the mountain, with many kids not seeing the outside world until they turned 16 or 18.

Women Knitted 56 Pairs of Wool Socks Each Fall

Women worked very hard, knitting dozens of heavy wool socks for each family before winter came. Nancy Gibbons alone made 56 pairs each fall just for her family.

Daily life meant carrying water from springs, cutting endless wood for heat and cooking, and saving food using old methods.

The blacksmith shop kept tools working and fixed all the metal items needed for mountain farming. Families raised animals, grew crops, and hunted for all their food.

They mostly traded goods with each other, only using cash from moonshine sales.

Young Men Left for War and Coal Mines After 1940

The settlement started to shrink when young men joined the military during World War II.

Others left for steady jobs in the coal mines, liking regular pay better. Nicey Ann Hensley died in 1937, marking the start of the end for the community.

The number of people dropped fast as younger folks chose modern comforts over isolated mountain life. When the school closed in 1947 after 39 years, it showed the community couldn’t last much longer.

Sherman Lived Alone at Age 68 as Buildings Crumbled Around Him

By 1949, the population shrank to just Sherman Hensley, living alone on the mountaintop at 68 years old. He kept up basic farming and still made moonshine.

The last resident tried to take care of the buildings and fields, but it was too much work without help from family. The settlement graveyard held 37 graves of people.

All these people had lived and died on the isolated mountain plateau. Sherman finally faced facts that his mountain community couldn’t go on without young people.

The Last Resident Left Behind 45 Empty Buildings in 1951

Sherman Hensley finally left the property in 1951 at age 70, ending nearly half a century of mountain life.

Without people to care for them, the settlement buildings quickly started falling apart as nature took back the land. He left behind 45 structures that showed how people once lived completely on their own in the 20th century.

Cumberland Gap National Historical Park was created on July 4, 1959, including the empty Hensley Settlement. The remote community became a ghost town.

Job Corps Workers Rebuilt the Ghost Town in 1965

The National Park Service teamed up with the Job Corps to restore the settlement in 1965. Workers brought 45 structures back to life, making the community look like it did during its 1925 peak.

Young Job Corps trainees learned building skills while they rebuilt log cabins, the schoolhouse, and the blacksmith shop.

The Hensley Settlement opened as a living history museum showing how people once lived self-sufficiently in the Appalachian mountains.

Today, visitors can tour the preserved community through guided tours from Cumberland Gap National Historical Park.

Visiting Cumberland Gap National Historic Park, Virginia

You can explore the Hensley Settlement at Cumberland Gap National Historic Park through guided van tours from the visitor center at 91 Bartlett Park Road in Middlesboro, Kentucky.

These 4.5-5 hour tours run mid-May through October and cost $10 for adults, $5 for seniors and kids 12 and under. You must call 606-248-2817 by noon the day before to reserve your spot on the 10-passenger shuttle.

This article was created with AI assistance and human editing.

Read more from this brand:

• The parkway that erased Appalachian communities in the name of tourism
• Gen. MacArthur and the 70,000 soldiers he left to the Bataan Death March
• Against all odds, MacArthur pulled off the perfect invasion — then lost everything to his ego